What is your contribution to the greater good of mankind David G.

# David G

You state:

"That anyone would claim that what Israeli Jews do is for mankind is laughable, almost deranged. Jews, as the superior, exalted, self-appointed Children of God, do everything purely for themselves, that and to make money."

Thanks for finally exposing yourself as a rabid Jew-hater. It has been a pleasure seeing your raw nerve exposed until you could not contain yourself any longer.

I wonder if you might change your mind if G-d forbid you one day contract any illness where your life could be saved with Israeli technology or medical know how.

Or would you refuse such treatment as a matter of principle?

What interests me is how you came to be such an all encompassing Jew-hater who cannot see any good in at least some Jews. Perhaps you can enlighten me on what happened that brought you to espouse the above views.

David Singer, you ask why I'm not enamored with Israeli Jews who in turn are supported by many Jews world-wide (but thankfully not all).

The answer is simple. I've watched them deliberately crushing the Palestinians for the last decade or more using their free American arms and Apache gunships and tanks and warships. I've watched in horror, footage of IDF brutality, of their deliberate cruelty. I've seen the ultra-othodox Jews standing looking at the carnage being carried out on Gaza as if it were a soccer game. I've seen a Palestinian family picnicking on a beach being blown up.

I've seen the bodies of Palestinian children who had been shot in the head by IDF snipers as they played outside their homes. I've watched the anguish in the faces of Palestinian farmers as their olive groves were bulldozed. I've seen the fear in the faces of Palestinian children as tanks pass their front doors or helicopters circle overhead ready to fire missiles. I've seen Palestinian boys with their legs and/or arms blown off by Israeli missiles and tank shells. I've seen the bulldozing of Palestinian homes as the Israeli government carries out collective punishment.

I saw the deliberate running down of Rachael Correy by an Israeli bulldozer, the shooting of journalists who dared to record Israeli war crimes. I've seen the use of phosphorous shells on Gaza, the taking away of Palestinian men who languish in Israeli jails without trial. I've watched women at Israeli checkpoints who were forced to give birth there because they weren't allowed through. I've watched the building of settlements and concrete walls all over the West Bank, the destruction of Jenin.

I won't list all the things I've seen but there's enough there to give you some idea why I feel the way I do.

By their actions, ye shall know them!

#David G

You state:

"David Singer, you ask why I'm not enamored with Israeli Jews who in turn are supported by many Jews world-wide (but thankfully not all)"

That is not what I asked.

Perhaps you might this time answer what I asked you- which was:

"What interests me is how you came to be such an all encompassing Jew-hater who cannot see any good in at least some Jews.Perhaps you can enlighten me on what happened that brought you to espouse the above views."

Those views expressed by you were clear and unambiguous:

"Jews, as the superior, exalted, self-appointed Children of God, do everything purely for themselves, that and to make money."

Don't try and crawl under a rock. Is this what you believe?

A YES or NO answer is all I require.

Oh dear.
Poor David G. You have fallen into the zionists trap and now he will shrilly denounce you as antisemetic. Your generalisations about jews leaves you open to it. Although I despise the jewish religion and all other religions I have learned that it is unwise to mention jews too often. The best way is to just refer to israel or isrealis or zionists.

Anyway you can just ignore singers question or say it isnt relevant. He does it to me all the time.

Algoreperson

I have said it before The lives of the living take precedence over the dead. What happened 2000 years ago has no bearing on todays situation in the middle east. The living, breathing people of the west bank and gaza did nothing to the jews of jesus day so why should they be punished with expulsion and dispossession? Why cant we go back further to the time of the Canaanites. The Canaanites slaughtered by the jews on their gods orders. One of the most heinous crimes ever committed if you have read your bible. Why isnt it the land of Canaan?

Does this philosophy of yours of recovering peoples ancient homelands extend to the aborigines? Or American Indians? Or any other of the many dispossessed peoples in this world? If not why not? Whats the difference? Maybe you will answer since singer could not.

Oh dear.
Poor Mikk You have fallen into the trap of believing the bible-stories literally.

Recent research indicates that the Canaanites and most of the Israeli tribes (except Levy) are one and the same. The bible portraid wars between the "two" in order to conceal the embarassing facts that Israelis used to worship different gods; did not all come from the same legendary ancesstors; and most of them were not slaves in Egypt or received the Torah on Mt. Sinai.

Sorry to spoil this particular argument of yours.
I do agree with you that the living take precedence over the dead and I wish that both Arabs and Jews were able to accept this principle as well.