The Forum > General Discussion > Should we change the date of Australia Day?
Should we change the date of Australia Day?
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 18
- 19
- 20
- Page 21
- 22
- 23
- 24
- ...
- 28
- 29
- 30
-
- All
The National Forum | Donate | Your Account | On Line Opinion | Forum | Blogs | Polling | About |
Syndicate RSS/XML |
|
About Us :: Search :: Discuss :: Feedback :: Legals :: Privacy |
There's no data to suggest a pre 1788 population of 700,000, the figure of 200,000 is just as credible, again, these figures are arrived at by mathematical modelling, ie they're a guess.
There are studies quoted in the Dowling paper which dismiss the idea of epidemics and allege widespread and systematic violence by Whites as the sole cause of the "Genocide".
You keep mentioning "Nazi Germany" as if it's some fait accompli in your argument but all it does is lend credence to the case against a systematic extermination campaign as the hard facts about the 1941-45 events in Poland don't support the idea of genocide.
Prison camps generally in the 20th century had about a 4-7% death rate from infection, with much higher tolls where infection control broke down or was absent.
The SS were able to keep the death toll to about 4% through constant testing of inmates, heavy use of insecticides and disinfectants in the camp and advanced techniques such as autoclave and microwave sterilisation of equipment.
When infection control broke down in in 1944-45 in several of the camps thousands died of typhus and dysentry, hence the piles of bodies at Belsen and the thousand or so dead at Buchenwald.
I know you like to use your imagination so picture the situation at an Aboriginal mission in the early 19th century with people wandering in and out as they felt like it, sick people mingling with newcomers, no vaccines,insecticides or disinfectants, poor rations and people debilitated by grog and chronic health problems.
It's no wonder that at times the town camps and out stations were found littered with corpses.
The other issue is that the introduced diseases took the heaviest toll on pregnant women, imagine the psychological effect on a clan of say 100 people of losing 30 of their number usually all the children under 15 and all their expectant mothers. Despair set in and the tribal order collapsed, men stopped hunting, women stopped gathering and the survivors fell into ruin, took to grog and existed by begging or stealing from the settlers.