The Forum > Article Comments > To London Muslims - speak out or be condemned for your silence > Comments
To London Muslims - speak out or be condemned for your silence : Comments
By Irfan Yusuf, published 8/7/2005Irfan Yusuf sends a message to London Muslims in the wake of the terrorist bombings across the city.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- Page 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- ...
- 22
- 23
- 24
-
- All
John lennons song "imagine" is one of the most shallow, dishonest(or plain ignorant), crude and time wasting efforts of musicla lyrics I've ever come across, not to mention 'unworkable and not a true portrayal of either human nature of history'.
Ifan, I applaud 'your' call, and support you. I only have that little niggling voice deep inside which says "Irfan is a great guy, says all the right things, wouldn't hurt a fly" but unfortunately "Irfan is not the agenda driver in Islam". I won't revisit that issue :) Still, to the extent you can raise awareness of the need to be peaceful, it's helpful.
I do find it a tiny bit out of character with the founder and foundations of Islam, as I've outlined in other places, but enuf of that for now.
"good on ya moit"
Now, back to Di.- If the values of "imagine" were followed, there would be total chaos. "Imagine all the people, living for today" yeah RIGHT... "Hedonism, pleasure,riches, me me meeeeeeeeeeeeeee...." living for today. There is no tomorrow, so why worry about it, fill your life and mind with sensuality, with existentially mind blowing experiences of ultimate intensity.. etc. That is the LOGICAL outcome (though not the 'practical-in-the-context-of-culture' one.) Reference to that song is like a red rag to an angry bull with me.
Its like throwing the 'one' of the latest fad toys into a group of preschoolers and singing "Imagine how they will share"..... duh.