Hi Nutter,

You lost me there - are you saying that the Jews in Germany were firing rockets into German towns, so the Nazis used this as a pretext for collecting, concentrating and exterminating them ?

Let me go out on a limb here and suggest that, quite possibly, not a single Jew ever fired a single rocket into a single German town. Of course, you may assert something different since it would be essential to your case.

But he who asserts must provide evidence: as Hitchen's Razor shows, an assertion without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.

Joe

Joe
It seems to me you were lost, in more than one way, long before I came on the scene.

Mate you should read Churchill and Chesterton. Both say the same as I say.

Perhaps they will be lost on you too?

Tell me after you have read their views on Judaism and Islam.

Yu

see as I suspected the issue of vengeance is too difficult for you to address.

It is a fundamental belief of Judaism and one used by the Israelis extremists in government to justify their use of violence and conducting an ethnic cleansing of Palestinians in both Gaza and the West Bank. (Take a look at the unseemly argument in the Israeli cabinet after the the peace was forced on Netanyahu by the Yanks when they cut of the supply of munitions.)

Now that I have simplified things for you try and address that issue in your simple way.

Thanks for clarifying your question, Imajulianutter:

The fact that some Jews/Israelis do what they do for stupid and wrong reasons, doesn't change the fact that they are protecting my family there. I obviously do not agree with their motives, but I am relieved that due to their actions my family is alive and well, so I thank them for that.

Hi Nutter,

Your appeal to the authority of a couple of conservatives can be dismissed, using Hitchens' Razor, as any appeal to authority can.

Perhaps you could try to answer my question. Or are you content in using any feeble excuse to attack the right of Israel to exist ? Even of Jews to exist ?

Good luck.

Joe

Loudmouth

Mate dismiss great western liberal democratic philosophers and heroes as conservatives is behaviour typical of low brow socialists.

You seem confused in your beliefs, unkind people would suggest shifty.

I am having a giggle at your gymnastics especially when your foot is stuck firmly in your mouth.

Watch for my response to your good Samaratin parable. It really is funny. Probably tomorrow. I want to share it with my literary mates at breakfast first.

They always appreciate lead footed stupidity.