Belly: The question in my humble view is;
are we better served by bringing the trash home and putting them in prison.

No that would cost the Taxpayer to look after them. Free food & lodging, medication, etc. & run anti-western seminars in the prisons. After that let them out to cause havoc in our streets.

Belly: The question in my humble view is;
should we shut the door and let them be killed over there.

The only solution is to let the Country they waged War in deal with them.

Belly: The question in my humble view is;
get a chance to be free and maybe commit more crimes/murders.

Which is exactly what would happen. These people are the Fanatics of Fanatics. That includes their Wives & Children, who give the utmost support & belief in their Caliphate.

Every year in Australia there is an Islamic Forum held discussing "The Great Southern Caliphate" Australia. Many years ago when the Ayatollah Khomeini visited Australia he made a speech to the moslims imploring them to get as many moslims into ?Australia as they could because, "Australia is a Religious desert & ripe for Conversion to Islam." That was in the early 70's & look what has happened since them.

Well done Steelie. One would expect you to play Devils Advocate. Especially when you appear to support these Criminals in every way.

p1405: but sometimes the wrong bastards get shot.

But not in this case.

p1405: Being in Australia we would have better control and monitoring than if they were roaming freely around some lawless state in the Middle East.

Better Control? When there are supporters the likes of you & steelie & lot of others we haven't heard from for some time. Yes Control like monitoring Rapists & Child molesters & other Criminals, people with mental Health Problems that are let out of Care. Yes I can see where the Authorities would have better Control. NOT.

The Pollies that allowed these people come to Australia in the first place should be charged. It should be mandated that if they return they should live next door to a Greens candidate, Kevin Rudd or Phelps.

Interesting opinions every one of them
My fear remains our courts are not to be trusted
My view is much like Foxy,s
And surely if we think about it, our very law and fairness is just what terrorists use against us
Every murder, from the young women bought and sold as slaves to be headings, should remind us we are not dealing with human beings
In time to come we will, a we must, take much harsher action against these people
Today a not Muslim murderer/terrorist was sentenced to serve at least 48 years in prison
That, at last, is a sentence that suits the crime

Paul,

"You can never defeat an enemy who will never give up."

Spot on there!
The English found this out after invading Ireland in 1170.

is Mise,
so what do you suggest ? Give up ?

Jayb,
Australia has never dealt harshly with criminals but the authorities do come down heavy on citizens who do it tough because of a rotten bureaucracy.
Australia should not spend another Cent on these sub humans & their supporters that joined IS. Let them become victims of those whom they wanted to make victims of.