The Forum > General Discussion > Monckton's New Party Concept
Monckton's New Party Concept
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Page 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
-
- All
The National Forum | Donate | Your Account | On Line Opinion | Forum | Blogs | Polling | About |
Syndicate RSS/XML |
|
About Us :: Search :: Discuss :: Feedback :: Legals :: Privacy |
But you need to be careful with your slogans.
>>Brave Heart,"They can take our lives but will never take our freedoms!That is the basic urge in all good men and women..."<<
Braveheart was a movie. Those words represent the basic urge of Hollywood scriptwriters to manipulate their audience.
Hollywood romances are not reality, Arjay. Even though Wallace is undoubtedly a significant character in Scottish history, very little is actually known of the man, let alone anything he might have said.
The earliest record of Wallace was in the form of a poem, written some two hundred years later by Blind Harry, a writer of heroic couplets. The Hollywood scriptwriter of his time, if you will.
The script of Braveheart was even more manipulative of history.
In his pre-battle speech, Wallace is heard to refer to a hundred years of oppression, whereas in fact that century was almost entirely peaceful between the English and the Scots. It was only in 1296, a year before Stirling Bridge, that Edward I decided to revive the English claims to overlordship of Scotland.
The movie also describes an affair between Wallace and Isabelle (Isabella) of France, hinting that she was pregnant with a son who would become Edward III of England.
Aaaah, romance.
Unfortunately for the happy-ending-seekers, i) Isabella was nine years old at the time, ii) was living in France, and even Blind Harry didn't mention Wallace ever left Scotland and iii) Edward III was born in 1312, while Wallace was executed in 1305.
The thing about history is that it is real. It is occasionally captured in documentaries, but they are extremely rarely told from any objective standpoint. Compare the different versions of the Battle of Waterloo, for example. The only reality of Braveheart was that Mel Gibson is an actor of some considerable talent.
>>A nation of obedient drones is impotent,boring and in the throes of decay.<<
Not necessarily. The Third Reich was big on obedience. But hardly impotent or boring.