The Forum > Article Comments > Wilderian far-right an instructive nuisance > Comments
Wilderian far-right an instructive nuisance : Comments
By Uthman Badar, published 22/2/2013In the past Wilders has called for things like the banning of the Quran, a tax on the hijab, a ban on Muslim immigration, a ban on building of mosques, and shooting youth of Moroccan descent.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- Page 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
-
- All
http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/4264412.html
http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/4270342.html
The first is by 2 Muslim women; they claim the Film "is a horribly Orientalist portrayal of Islam, one in which the Prophet Mohammed is portrayed in the most offensive of ways."
In rejecting satire directed at Islam they slur orientals! The rest of the article is a panegyric about the religion of peace with no sense of irony that criticism of Islam is because it is not what it says it is and that people judge it on its actions rather than its hypocritical disclaimers.
The second article does not even bother with such subtleties [sic]. In it Morsi justifies the non-moderate muslim who rejects what he sneeringly describes as the "good citizen" by "pushing back the police picket line to create new forms of citizenry."
The author of this piece is another 'academic' Muslim who rejects the secular society. Badar's other piece at Unleashed does so on the pretext that secularism is irrational while a religious belief like Islam is rational:
http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/42672.html
This is telling:
"Devoid of a rational argument for secularism (compromise solutions are never strictly rational), advocates resort to a rather romanticised view of it as a neutral system which allows for a pluralist society where everyone is free to practice their individual beliefs. Yet secularism is built on a specific worldview and is no more neutral than any other ideology. It disallows those parts of other worldviews which contradict with it, just as they would."
This is junk. Badar is saying that because secularism prevents monolithic world views like Islam from stopping other religious or non-religious views secularism is as bad as Islam is made out to be. In short secularism is bad and irrational because it does not allow Islam to eradicate other world views.
Such is the 'intellectual' justification for Islam.