The Forum > Article Comments > On Spiritual Atheism > Comments
On Spiritual Atheism : Comments
By Ben-Peter Terpstra, published 17/5/2011To whom or what was Julia Gillard praying, since she tells us she has no god.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 7
- 8
- 9
- Page 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- ...
- 59
- 60
- 61
-
- All
<<Inventors, Engineers and Scientists do not sit around awaiting 'evidence' AJ.>>
And why would they? No-one was obliged to provide it. If a god exists and is threatening us with eternal consequences, then that god is obliged to prove their existence to us beyond any reasonable doubt.
Furthermore, the Abrahamic god allegedly wants a relationship with us but apparently can’t be bothered putting any effort into reaching out to us in any way that can’t be explained through other more rational means; at least not to those of us who understand the nature of evidence since he’s relying texts, anecdotal testimony and old languages that die out.
<<There is no evidence that a certain invention (after spending time, resources and money)will ever eventuate or be successful.>>
No, but we can apply what we do already know to arrive at a certain level of certainty that it will be successful and if it isn’t, then it’s abandoned. Very different from making something up, only to then - when there is no evidence for it and even evidence to the contrary - place it in an untouchable transcendent realm to avoid ever having to abandon it and protect it from the only reliable methods we currently have for investigating reality.
The faith you refer to in your analogy is a justified confidence in the eventual success of something. “Religious faith”, on the other hand, is merely hope and desire mistaken for knowledge. Even if they were the same kinds of “faith”, your analogy would STILL be woefully inaccurate because the “faith” that engineers/scientists/etc start off with is no longer required once their ideas are made reality. Religion, however, will always require faith and even theists themselves admit this.
How is it that we use reason and evidence in every endeavour of our lives but then when it comes to the ultimate and most important truth, theists say faith is required?
What kind of a god requires faith instead of evidence?