Jail doesn't work in Australia because there is no jail, they're all more like motels. Gym rooms, reading rooms, TV, internet, studies etc etc.
Once they actually build proper jails, criminals will reconsider.

indy tell us how you know what they are like, from the inside? how does your view impact on this thread? should we flog them as well as make them pay? I remain convinced our justice system should be able to make the better off pay for time served, could include even the costs of catching them but will be happy if we get part of my wish

Dear Individual,

One day it could be you or one of your family, possibly for a crime you/they never committed, thus cannot reconsider.

Hi there Individual...

I understand precisely what it is you're saying about how our gaols are going soft. And I agree with you. There's no real punishment by sending a recidivist to prison. Other than the deprivation of his liberty, which can, in some small measure, 'cramp his style' somewhat.

Unfortunately my friend, as long as I've been in the coppers (32+ years), the official mantra has always been, 'a person is sent to prison as a punishment, not 'FOR' punishment'. Which means governments can virtually allow anything (within reason) into a gaol that will keep prisoners quiet, and settled.

It often remains within the purview of the Corrective Services Minister, or the Commissioner, what Inmates can get of can't get. Often unintentionally putting at risk the lives of Prison Officers who have to work there. I might add, it's generally accepted, the current Commission is a real dud, and should never have been appointed.