The Forum > General Discussion > Gillard has Lowered Feminine Aspirations
Gillard has Lowered Feminine Aspirations
- Pages:
-
- 1
- Page 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- ...
- 11
- 12
- 13
-
- All
Posted by The Blue Cross, Monday, 5 September 2011 9:05:17 AM
| |
True to a degree Blue Cross but Labor at least should have found a woman half credible and intelligent enough to hold the position pf PM.
Posted by Arjay, Monday, 5 September 2011 10:11:33 AM
| |
TBC:"I think it unfair to taint 'women' with Gillard, or to expect Gillard to be 'a woman'. Such thinking is silly, misdirected and worthless."
Not at all. Gillard is a founding member of Emily's List and has gained special treatment as a result. All the ALP women are members of Emily's list with the exception of those who refuse to support "pro-choice", which is a primary ideology. http://www.emilyslist.org.au/our-mps Kate Lundy Gai Brodtmann Sharon Grierson Julie Owens Tanya Plibersek Janelle Saffin Jill Hall Sharon Bird Justine Elliot Trish Crossin Jan Mc Lucas Claire Moore Kirsten Livermore Anne McEwen Penny Wong Carol Brown Julie Collins Lisa Singh Julia Gillard Catherine King Jenny Macklin Laura Smyth Louise Pratt Melissa Parke State Parliamentarians Katy Gallagher ACT Kirin MacDonald ACT Mary Porter ACT Linda Burney NSW Noreen Hay NSW Sonia Hornery NSW Christine Robertson NSW Penny Sharpe NSW Carmel Tebbutt NSW Lynda Voltz NSW Helen Westwood NSW Jane Aagaard NT Alison Anderson NT Delia Lawrie NT Malarndirri McCarthy NT Marion Scrymgour NT Anna Bligh QLD Desley Boyle QLD Jan Jarratt QLD Jo-Ann Miller QLD Lindy Nelson-Carr QLD Rachel Nolan QLD Desley Scott QLD Christine Smith QLD Judy Spence QLD Barbara Stone QLD Karen Struthers QLD Frances Bedford SA Lyn Breuer SA Giles Gago SA Robyn Geraghty SA Stephanie Key SA Grace Portolesi SA Jennifer Rankine SA Gay Thompson SA Lara Giddings TAS Michelle O'Byrne TAS Jacinta Allan VIC Liz Beattie VIC Candy Broad VIC Lily D'Ambrosio VIC Kaye Darveniza VIC Joanne Duncan VIC Maree Edwards VIC Jane Garrett VIC Judith Graley VIC Danielle Green VIC Jill Hennessy VIC Natalie Hutchins VIC Sharon Knight VIC Jenny Mikakos VIC Lisa Neville VIC Bronwyn Pike VIC Jaala Pulford VIC Fiona Richardson VIC Gayle Tierney VIC Sue Ellery WA Carol Martin WA Sally Talbot WA Lisa Baker WA Janine Freeman WA Alannah Mactiernan WA Linda Savage W Can you ppoint to an equivalent group of men who identify primarily as men and only secondarily as MPs? Posted by Antiseptic, Monday, 5 September 2011 10:12:07 AM
| |
I actually give Julia Gillard alot more credit then many others
on OLO do. Her real problem is the division in her own party and having to concede to the Greens to form Govt. That has put her between a rock and a hard place on things like the carbon tax and the boat people question. Its women such as Sarah Palin and Michelle Bachmann which I am really nervous about. Woe betide the world, if one of them should gain office. Posted by Yabby, Monday, 5 September 2011 10:15:51 AM
| |
Forgive me Arjay, but I am unaware of any women in the ALP suitable to be elevated to PM.
That said, I despair over the men too. And what/whom from the Coalition? Julie Bishop (hahahaha) or Sophie, a female version of Abbott-Heffernan? Perhaps you can assist with a few nominees? Posted by The Blue Cross, Monday, 5 September 2011 10:16:14 AM
| |
Re an election, the independants have said they would continue to
support the government if Gillard it tipped out. Of course to do otherwise would put them out of a job and parliament. I do not think we will go to an early election, we may go all the way to early 2004. I think it can go for a few months over the three years. From what I read, growth is very low and that probably means increasing unemployment. This will upset many of the rusted on and may change their vote. It will not matter what party gets elected, unemployment will increase but later on there will be increasing opportunities for manufacturing. I just cannot see Gillard ever understanding what the British govt has found on future fuel, even though they are like rabbits in the headlights. Yes, I don't expect the opposition to be any better on that matter either. Posted by Bazz, Monday, 5 September 2011 10:22:43 AM
|
Hardly. The hagiography by Jacqueline Kent on Gillard is worth a read, but first read Christine Wallace's opinion on it:
"The Making of Julia Gillard provides a plain-vanilla account of Gillard’s progress from Gillard’s point of view and an uncomplicated description of some arcane aspects of Labor’s factional history. If the truth is in the surface of things – as André Gide remarked – then Kent has done a good job of description without analysis. That will be fine with most of the people involved in this book, none more so than Gillard herself." (http://www.themonthly.com.au/books-christine-wallace-other-biography-jacqueline-kent039s-quotthe-making-julia-gillardquot-2015).
Of course, Wallace is an ALP machinery part, so be warned.
However, my reading of Gillard in this hagiography showed her to be the shallowest of people imaginable. Dedicated to the ALP machine above everything else. Having affairs with rightwingers all the time, while pretending to be 'left'.
Belly is correct, she did back Latham, the monster from Hell, but only because it provided a way forward for her while he was there.
His politics were always as credible as hers though, so they deserved each other.
I think it unfair to taint 'women' with Gillard, or to expect Gillard to be 'a woman'. Such thinking is silly, misdirected and worthless.
Why not expect all politicians, male and female, to be credible worthwhile people, and leave gender out of it?
Gillard is neither credible nor worthwhile, but she is not alone in our nations parliaments is she?
These places of privileged ignorance abound with men, many of whom show no signs of ability either.