Pauliar,

You didn't put the word they in you put the word "the" in which I thought was just another grammatical cock up on your part.

You are lying and being DECEITFUL by claiming that you put in the word 'they'

SM,

Life in YOUR Capitalist utopia of INDIA must be wonderful for some, but not for the 83.8%, and rising, of INDIANS living in poverty, that's 1,100,000,000 people. YES! 1,100,000,000 people in poverty, what an achievement for INDIA who have followed the Capitalist pathway for the past 75 years since Independence from the oppressive British Empire!

YOU gave me the Capitalist website 'macrotrends' to claim China has 24.7%, and declining, of its people living in poverty, a figure not supported by the World Bank, but if true, not acceptable in anyone's language, good to see the Chinese government is working for the people to eradicate any poverty that might exist, with a Socialist system supporting the impoverished.

shadowminister, why are YOU refusing to give an explanation for INDIA'S 83.8% POVERTY, YOU POSTED THE WEBSITE! Hey fess up, that you stuffed up! Now you want to shut up!

Paul,

Life in YOUR communist utopia must be fantastic with 25% living in poverty 50 million dying of starvation and on average earning about 1/3rd of the amount of those in TAIWAN the part of China with democracy and capitalism and not communism.

No matter how much of a shill YOU ARE you can't beat the numbers.

SM,

I asked YOU to give an explanation for the 83.8% of INDIANS living in poverty according to YOUR website supplied 'macrotrends' Just to remind YOU that's 1,100,000,000 people. No need for YOUR pathetic attempts at deflection. Just answer the question.

FESS UP, YOU STUFFED UP, NOW YOU WANT TO SHUT UP! The dog has been cornered!

Pauliar,

You said "Under Communism, China has full employment"

You then tried to compare this to India which is a different culture and background when the real comparison is with Taiwan.

You also failed to explain why communism is so great after the CCP deliberately starved 50 000 000 people in the great leap forward. PLEASE EXPLAIN.

FESS UP, YOU STUFFED UP, NOW YOU WANT TO SHUT UP! YOU HAVE been cornered!

Shonky,

Stop the deflection, my question is very simple, INDIA with a similar size in population, area, location, resources as CHINA, has according to YOUR source data 'macrotrends' 83.8% living in poverty under Capitalism, and CHINA as a Socialist state 24.7%, again from your source 'macrotrends'. Economically CHINA has gone ahead in leaps and bounds, whilst INDIA remains the biggest basket case in Asia.

Just as I don't compare the living standards of folks living in the Sydney suburb of Vaucluse with folks like you living in Shalvey, you're all Sydneysiders. I don't compare one small Chinese province with the rest of China.

BTW, I have a good friend in Sydney from Taiwan, she is very concerned about her family back home. I support independence for Taiwan, without American use of the island as an aggressive base for destabilisation and militarism against the people of mainland China.

ANSWER THE QUESTION!