The National Forum   Donate   Your Account   On Line Opinion   Forum   Blogs   Polling   About   
The Forum - On Line Opinion's article discussion area



Syndicate
RSS/XML


RSS 2.0

Main Articles General

Sign In      Register

The Forum > Article Comments > Plain packaging does more harm than good > Comments

Plain packaging does more harm than good : Comments

By David Leyonhjelm, published 5/5/2014

But while it failed to reduce smoking rates, plain packaging has led Australia into a legal minefield.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. 3
  5. 4
  6. Page 5
  7. 6
  8. 7
  9. 8
  10. 9
  11. 10
  12. 11
  13. All
OUG, what is it with you, if it's not bombarded with a thousand links, your posts are full of abbreviations and capitals.

Why on earth can't you simply post in plain simple to understand English.

Honestly, I give up!
Posted by rehctub, Thursday, 8 May 2014 8:26:06 AM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
butch/we know/where you stand/YOU CANT REFUTE.SO YOU POLUTE/ridicule

butch/said..<<..the fee..would have most definitely.been 'passed on' it would have...fixed.....edited....the loople [?]in the online GST fiasco.>>

pot/kettle

RECtum/quote..<<..What governments..need to decide,
is do..they want to..stop smoking,...or don't they.>>

I WISh..it.*was banned/that way..nO MORE..30 BILION DOLLARS OF REVENUE FROM US SMOKERS/NO_.ONE..WANTS TO PAY tax/but ban it..i dare you stop..benefiting...from it

your two-faced..tax Me to death..with
*30 billion..-in sin-taxes[ANNUALLY]

<<several angles/that..won't see....them..[YOU]..being sued.>>

THERE IS..NO ONE LEFT..TO SUE...each smoker
PAYS HIS 4000 DOLLARS[per/year]..IN TAX HAPPY/till they see through the spin/and realize..how...royally[/grossly...WE HAVE..BEEN SCREWED

<<ban smaokng..from...any public place,>>
thEY HAVE/plus....4 METERS FROM DOORWAY/YET..WHEN I tested THE law
any\thought..of allowing mE..TO TEST THE Law/was simply taken away

[there was no tape/LOST..VOICE
RECORDINGS..ETC/but..you/OL/HOLE..fool/its so/

deals..IS..done

<<ban smoking/from all..workplaces,>>
done..[since/1951/
THE/SLAUGHTERING ACT/of=]1951..butchers/got done.
SMOKING/OR/EXPECTORATINg..PENALTY 50 pounds/how many times..you GET DUN?

<<ban smoking/from..any clubs,>
done

<<..any moving\vehicle>>
IN PROCESS

<<..smoke*on..ones lap>>

your..a sick bloke/butche

<<far more distracting/than..using a mobil..[MOBIlE/WHAT?].in hand while driving.>

yes..dont smoke..and drive

get angry/instead..
new-age*..road*rage*

<<>>governments can/ban smoking..from anywhere>>>

please explain how/..by what right?
que warrento butch

<<>.other than/a persons ..wn private property >>

NOT SO BUTCH/THEY SMEL THE SMOKE
DONT BE..THE JOKE bloke..one sniff/were outcast/EVER SMEED OUR STINK/THINK*

,<<<the minute...anyone steps out their gate
with a lit cigarete..they can be finned.>>

AND YOU TALK..OF ..FINE=FINE..IF ITS MINE?

<<>..Of cause..they won't,>>

i knOW THEY JUST WALK IN

<<>.because they rely so heavily.on the tax revenue.>>[finaLy/thankyou]

EXACTLY..SEE HOW/even/\THIS SMALL INCREASE/YET RAISES AN EXTRA 3 BILLION..ON TOP OF THe 26 billion..it raises..[EACH YEAR]..just iN THESE EASTERN STATES

FREEDOM OF INFO..WILL REVEAL

<<As with/many things
now,..it's a double edged sword.>>>

YES IT IS BUTCH
IT IS SO..

THESe FRAUD/HEALTH MORALISAtion laws..havE TO GO
YOU CANT EVER AFORD TO PAY US BACK/thiS COLUDED Treasonous trilion dollar fraud

SO BACK OFF..JACK A REAL LAWYER..WOULD GUT THE..'LAW'...EXCEPT THE LAWYERS came up with it/...causE GOVT..CAN TAKE TAX AND..THEY ARE GOOD AT ACCESSING ANY GOVT CASH COW.FOR A MATE..

mate..how many..SMOKERS EVER DIED..'SMOKING'[THE/dead cant smoke]
but..SMOKING HAS NEVER..'CAUSED' ANY 'DEath..[cause thats calLed arsefiXation
Posted by one under god, Thursday, 8 May 2014 9:40:32 AM
Find out more about this user Visit this user's webpage Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
OUG, I read your post, hard work, but as it was aimed a me I thought I would.

What I am saying is that IF GOVERNMENTS WISH TO STOP SMOKING there are ways to achieve this without being sued by cig companies.

While cig companies may have the rights to their trade marked advertising, which is what they are fighting for, they can not sue a government that either bans the sales, or, hides the product from view. It's the changing of the packaging that has caused the issue, nothing else.

As for public places, that referee to anywhere outside of ones personal home/yard.

As for the four meter rule, I thought it was 3, shopping centers are the winners out of this, as many charge or review their rents on traffic numbers and, if you have 300 smokers in the centre, and each exits for ten smokes a day, that's fudging the figures.

As for my rules with regards to smoking in my shops, they were my shops and my rules. End of story.

But, as I say, it's like speeding fines and alike, if we all suddenly stop speeding, who pays the bills.

BTW, I am not suggesting they ban smoking.
Posted by rehctub, Thursday, 8 May 2014 11:21:25 AM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
BUTCH/I KNOW..no ban..[cOWARDS].
because...there/is stil..Too many OF US
AND..OUR/taxes..ARE PAYING..FOR one/twentieth..of fed buDGET..

its/just us..Payin/for all..of you/
but you..keep cutting/our.numbers..so even/more.debt falls back/on..us..few

its time..it/fell-BACK\on you.

<<..govt..STOP/SMOKING..without/sued..by.\cig companies.>>

mate/..the public-service..bought up..THE/voting shares/IN SMOKING PRODUCT/PRODUCERS..globally..SO THEY ARNT..Going to..*end..the cash-cow/..they have\the numbers

i dont care..<<>>what/they are..fighting for,
they..cannot sue.....a government that..either/bans..the sales>>

mate its..a laydown misere/..
PLUS..WITH VERY..*ACCURATE NUMBERS..TO GET Back..the last cent with intrest..

SEE/MATE..[its against treaties..govt has signed/big TOBACCO CANT LOOSE WITHOUT GOVT LOOSING EVEN MORE..[THE MORE/WHO-QUIT/THE MORE COMPO..[GET IT?]

<<>.It's the/changing..of\the packaging..
that has caused.. the issue, nothing else.>

[I DONT CARE..HOW MUCH IT COSTS..*YOU/
BUT ONCE..THEY GOT THE RESULT COurt RULING...they will have/your not going to be paying it...with/yet..another new..smoking-tax.

SO THE...[not sINEVITABLE/HUGE PAYOFF..TO BIG.TOBAcco

not/smokers?]..GOVT BETTER..BACK OFF..IT CANT GET OFF.

<<..each exits..for ten smokes..that's fudging/the figures.>>

we mate thanks..for telling me tHAT
I WILL ADVISE Smokers....at shopping centers to go in and out a few times and..up ya rent..

<<.As for my/rules with regards..to smoking in my shops,
they were my shops...and my rules....End of story.>>

GOVT Regulates..ALL MEAT/TYPE HANDLING/
'your' rules..wernt regulated/WATCHED/HOUNDED..MANDAted
imposed...by every mongrel..AND HIS DOG..WITH REAL MALICE AND Spite

IF WE DID..A work to rule...
on butchers..then/its your..over policed/buTT..THAT WOULD BE SORE

THING is butch
say..i came into your shop/and told you..this or that..is how..it wilL BE..like youR TELING ME/..BUT THE EXACT OPPOSITE/..YOU2..TOO wOULD SAY SCREW YOU/

WELL ME TOO

<<>>But, as I say,.it's like/speeding fines..and alike,..who pays the bills.>..

has taxation/without representation*
ie oppression/how dare..govt..declare war..on its ward

thise...WHO WANTS FREE STADIUM/OR BILLION DOLLAR MOTERraces?
get them to pay/make..the sports rorts..[that sent us broke..go away

re..nationalize...all infrastructure our taxes..BUILT
then..you wouldnt need..to pay tax/but.STILL/you hate me personalLY/ oo much

<<>.BTW...I am not suggesting..they ban smoking.>>

GUTless

weak as piss/..if you had guts...YOU WOULD try/to BAN IT
OR ELSE STOP GETTING THE ADVANTAGES OF BiIions..[trilions]..of our cash

but.for/blush..its..ok/its on me
not you/and i..dont even..*get one..freaking free scrap of tobacco..defending big freaking..SELL*OUTS TO/scamers

ban it...DO/it..
or..at/least...have..the principle
to refuse the money from.our..SICk/dead DYING HANDS..[its cursed]

taxing diabetics..would clearly reveal/the barsardry/clearly..a clue
of the vile..we must endure...because OF THE LIKES..oF BUSY/BLOGGER$..SUCH/as you.

ANYHOW\thanks..or helping me vent
Posted by one under god, Thursday, 8 May 2014 12:21:58 PM
Find out more about this user Visit this user's webpage Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
Go and have another ten fags OUG, That should settle you down, and help pay for a few non smoking related hand outs.
Posted by rehctub, Thursday, 8 May 2014 12:31:19 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
lets WRITE..REVERSE\PROPAGANDA/FACT-CHECKS..and OTHER.*INFO ON THE CIGGIE Butt*..or use that/new-additive..mandated/in ciggie-paper..to invert/lies\.PROPAGANDA.

this additive mandated/by\YOUR..GOVT..UNLAWFULY.

or..via ciggie cards..THAT STICKER..we can past-up..[IN SMOKING-AREAS]..to educate and inform..peers/..of..the high treason/govt mALFEASENCE....ODIOUS DEBT/CORRUPTION..OR THE Good wars..our CRIMINAL/CIGGIE-taxes..are paying for..

MANY OF YOU..ARE FORMER SMOKERS
WAS..IT..WORKPLACE polLution..[oror smoking_tax/cost]..that..*got you?

thing is...cancerOus/volitiles/particulates
perfumes/ADDITIVES..gmo's..and poisend WATER/food air
they/ARE..killing you..{MORE DIE BY SUICIDE/..MORE DIE BY/CAR/..MOre diabetes..tax lolies..if you dare

but..the author puts it better
THuS/BEWARE
<<>. plain packaging..has led Australia..into a legal minefield.

<<>>Major trading partner Indonesia, along with Ukraine, Cuba, Dominican Republic and Honduras have taken action through the World Trade Organisation to challenge Australia's plain packaging legislation,>>

[]with a further 35 countries possibly joining the dispute as third parties. They argue it creates an unnecessary barrier to trade in violation of our treaty obligations.[]

..,.Philip Morris Asia..is suing the Australian Government..under the terms of the Australia/Hong Kong Bilateral Investment Treaty,..which provides protections*..*for international investments..*in Australia including..*in intellectual property*.

[ITS/THE/LYING..THAT BRINGS\THE..bad-karma.]

<<..These two international cases,..which will be decided in the next two to three years,..>>[UNESS-SANITY ARISES][.IF ONlY/to halve..following payout..]..could prove financially disastrous.

[as/thEY..THEN\WI BE GIVING-SMOKES-AWAY]
100%..OF NUTHING=0

hahaha

<..An adverse result could find..[NON-SMOKING]..Australian taxpayers on the receiving end..of a compensation claim..worth billions of dollars.>>

THe..loss/of\tax-INCOME..flow=doublE=TRILION

<<.Former Fairfax business commentator,..Tim Colebatch,..said the WTO case."is shaping up...to become the biggest trade dispute Australia has ever faced..[as a defendant."]..>>>..winner=Take all.

There is another issue too..A recent KPMG study..found that since the introduction of plain packaging,..the black market in illicit tobacco in Australia has boomed,.growing by 19% in 2013,..and is now costing the government up to $1.1 billion in forgone annual tax revenue.>>

but/free-smokes..for SMOKERS[ONE pack-per/day]
busts/that criminal cycle-tOO*.

<<>>The report..?

<<>.also shows a 35% growth..in illicit tobacco consumption...since the 25% excise increase in April 2010...Australia already has the highest cigarette prices..*[in the region,]..a whopping..75% higher than Singapore,..[?}..so it's not hard to imagine..what the forthcoming series,..*of four annual 12.5% excise..increases will do to the illicit market...>>

the/WRITING..IS..ON../THE\..WALL...*
who takes the fall
thats allll
Posted by one under god, Saturday, 10 May 2014 8:06:52 AM
Find out more about this user Visit this user's webpage Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. 3
  5. 4
  6. Page 5
  7. 6
  8. 7
  9. 8
  10. 9
  11. 10
  12. 11
  13. All

About Us :: Search :: Discuss :: Feedback :: Legals :: Privacy