RObert yes he made that comment.
I stood in an office, leave it at that the day the Clown Latham told us he had hand picked a great singer to become a mediocre politician.
Garret went on to harm the pink bats issue and more.
The man who had been nominated by the branch he had been a long term active member of.
He was parachuted in, not before time, by the Sussex Street Mafia, as was Bob Carr after another Sussex Street tool , having undermined the party left.
However do not hold the party to account for Garret, he is a do it your self fool.

Pelican it is a lie when you emphatically state something , & then do the other.

You can't use that "had to do it to buy the Greens" rubbish. As I stated in an earlier post, the greens are welded on to Labor, & have no choice but to vote with them. It is either that or vote with the Libs. Suggesting they forced Gillard's hand is garbage, & you are smart enough to know this.

This woman has no honor, & no morals, & the sooner we are shot of her the better.

Graham Richardson said;

"Whatever it Takes"

i feel if we loooked back with hindsight
at the precise timmings of no tac govt i lead
plus the poll results ..of the time..it becomes clear hung govt was the only result

the no tax thing was a cheap..lie to get a few extra seats

we have her own words..we have the polls
we know she lied..wanted to traiter anyhow..its so pathetic

pay to the blind pete
opinion runs against you keeping that 50

but that was now seen to be a lie too

lie down with dogs get fleas
buyt im more intrested in trying to comprehend bellies last post

life a bit chh
if ya spinning half a wit chh
too close to the fire and red heads self combust

i seen it
buy a box of red heads..hold it near a nakid flame and see

for sense from nonsense
in the dollhouse..mothers/grandmothers only please

let the sisters go play their games as lobbiests
which they will in time become ..once they loose their seat*

sweet
im stil angry she visited that myssogenist [in alfganastan]
you know keisie the oine who hasnt opened a single GIRLS SCHOOL
who allows MYSOGENIST PRACTICES UPON THEIR WOMAN FOLK..

and there is that red head
running away from the flame to the fire
now shes going to deal with lower casts..in india next..
set up a few call centers full of woman..doing chick flick type work

lord juliar has awoken a sexist demon in me
she lied

pay up..to some charity
you both lost.

the more ya try to spin it
the more like each other you reveal yourself to be

too trickey
by half*..the pair of ya.

I am interested in Pelican's definition of a lie:

"Is it also a lie when a government uses a Senate majority to bring in legislation never revealed to the electorate prior to an election. eg. Workchoices. Not a lie technically but it was dishonest nevertheless"

So which of the 300 odd pieces of legislation that Juliar's government passed with a senate majority were explained to the electorate before the election. Were all of these lies?

So far we've had 8 pages, and not one person here has been able to show that the Prime Minister lied regarding her pre-election statement.

They have also displayed they lack English comprehension ability, as I specifically requested that the topic not contain "opinion". But many far right wingers are like that, and there's only a handful of them here on this topic. They are even trying to desperately redefine the meaning of the word lie ..... too funny indeed !!

Most of the replies have shown that it's clearly understood by intelligent people here that it was a broken commitment, not a lie. The majority of Aussies understand this by now.

For a lie to be a lie there MUST be intent to deceive.

The mere handful of far right wing intransigents here are continuing on with their name calling and personal abuse of the Prime Minister .... this reflects on "their" character and inability to debate the economy, education, health, defence. It's all about personal abuse and name calling to these far right wingers.

They love people like me to write posts like this. Why? Because it puts them at the centre of attention, and gives meaning to their existence. They come here, abuse the people they despise, and then feel important and powerful as a result. Their behaviour here says EVERYTHING about these handful of far right wingers.

And of course, not one of them has been able to prove that the Prime Minister lied.