The Forum > Article Comments > The irrational slide to Rudd > Comments
The irrational slide to Rudd : Comments
By Jonathan J. Ariel, published 12/9/2007The gravitation towards Rudd demonstrates an irrationality steeped in ignorance that flies in the face of logic.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 8
- 9
- 10
- Page 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
-
- All
The title and description is rather loaded. In labelling the slide to Rudd 'irrational' and saying that it is steeped in ignorance, he effectively labels all Australians who support Rudd over Howard (which according to the polls, is a majority) as ignorant and foolish for their selection.
So I suppose he can't be too wounded when they return serve - though I suppose certain responses make it easy for Mr Ariel to rationalise his view that it is ignorance that has created this situation.
There are two sides to this - the economic sphere, and the social sphere.
Given that Howard has embraced a 'large l' liberal policy of conservatism on the social matters, it's understandable that a great many Australians will disagree on many issues. I've often thought that while Australia is quite a conservative nation, it is not quite as conservative as it's government in many areas of social policy.
The economic argument is one that has plenty of facets as well - controlling inflation has been at the core of the argument, and fair enough - though the Howard government (partly due to federal-state grievances and the very structure of Australian government responsibilities) has dropped the ball on infrastructure.
Roads, water, health care - these are all in dire form. Technically, these are the responsibilities of the State, but the difficult issue we have, is that the State relies on federal funding for these issues, and we are continually faced with a situation wherein the Federal Government withholds cash until surplus time, then doles it out in a political manner. This won't change under Rudd, but the fact that the government has become a large, high taxing one, is a very rational reason.
There's plenty more reasons I can go into, but this will have to suffice for now...