The Forum > Article Comments > Human Rights Watch targets Israel > Comments
Human Rights Watch targets Israel : Comments
By Sarah Mandel, published 26/7/2006Political bias of HRW's Middle East division is regularly expressed in its disproportionate focus on Israel.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- Page 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
-
- All
Marilyn, I agree with most of your sentiment, but not that.
The jewish people specifically wanted their holy land.
Whether or not they would have accepted somewhere else is debatable, but the fact that they had their eyes on Israel as the prize is not - they've been pretty open about the for thousands of years.
Israel probably was about the worst place they could have been put, though there were going to be problems anywhere.
Say you put them on madagascar. There wouldn't necessarily be war with the madagascans, but there'd be problems. Displaced people.
If you want to see what happens when a people are displaced, look no further than the problems with aboriginal Australia, or the ongoing issues associated with land title and the New Zealand Maoris, or the disaffected native Americans.
You can argue that they should have been accepted as a part of western culture, but I would argue that they have.
The jewish people have suffered more than any culture and they deserved to have a home nation, though I'm not sure whether they deserved to have their prophecies realised with the establishment of the jewish state. Though where their nation should have been placed, I don't pretend to know.