The Forum > Article Comments > Are we deceived by multiculturalism? > Comments
Are we deceived by multiculturalism? : Comments
By Danny Nalliah, published 6/1/2006Danny Nalliah argues immigrants must be prepared to do more to assimilate into Australian society.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 7
- 8
- 9
- Page 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- ...
- 30
- 31
- 32
-
- All
"I assume when you live in these countries you assimilate and blend into the culture and lifestyle of these people and are well accepted as being Japanese, Korean, Taiwanese, Singaporian, and Chinese. Or are you always spoken of as being Australian. I would hope that migrant settlers to our country would consider themselves as firstly Australian before any of these races. If you lived permanently in Japan would you be Japanese?"
I'm not really sure what it means to "assimilate or blend into the culture and lifestyle". If you mean live within the bounds of the normal culture, then that would be true. Alternatively, it is very hard to think of what I could do in a place like Hong Kong that isn't also acceptable in Australia, or what I could do in Australia that also isn't acceptable in Hong Kong. Thus, at least for me, living a culturally acceptable lifestyle like the average person in Hong Kong isn't very much different than living a lifestyle like that in Australia.
As to whether different countries consider you as a member of their people after living their for long enough -- I think this differs on the country. There are certainly white people in Hong Kong that consider themselves Hong Kongkers, and Malays from Singapore that consider themselves Singaporean. Alternatively, as far as I'm aware, being Korean and Japanese is more based more on physical ethnic identity.
I don't see the identity acceptance as all-or-nothing issue and nor particularily to do with religion. Being o not fully Anglo, I doubt I could ever be considered French or Greek, even if I lived in those countries permanently, spoke the language without an accent etc. Thus, in that respect, those countries are more like Korea or Japan. The same is probably true for the first 20 or so years of my life in Australia. I very much doubt the average Australian would have considered me Australian despite being born in Australia, since physical ethnic identity (i.e., being white) was more important then (things are different now).