Dear David,

Did you mean this nonsense? http://english.alarabiya.net/in-translation/2022/06/08/The-Hashemite-Kingdom-of-Palestine

The author admits to being an Israel-hater (yet he tries to be realistic).

The specific problem he tries to solve is "the Palestinian problem", which is neither anything I care about nor your silly invented "100 years of conflict between Arabs and Jews" (and you still failed to provide a reason for your wanting to end it!).

Fine: he's an Arab after all.
Should Israel be destroyed as a result, the author would only rejoice.
Should Jordan be taken by Syria as a result, he wouldn't care either (both Sunni Arabs, aren't they?).

The author is either blind or deliberately lies when claiming that "Jordanians and Palestinians are as similar as any people can be", well for him, a Saudi, perhaps they both are equally just trouble which could destabilise his country.

The author is happy to ask the "Palestinians" (wherever they live) to ratify this plan - but how about asking Israelis and Jordanians too? no, for him they don't count!

The author admits to strong resistance from "some “East Jordanian” elites" (in fact the vast majority of Jordanians, that he wouldn't say), but believes that somehow... Israel, among others...would convince them otherwise - that Israel would sign its own death warrant... Ha Ha Ha.

The author considers the possibility of "Palestinians" rejecting the deal, but fails to look at the most likely scenario, of them verbally pretending to accept the deal, then the following day turning from within against these gullible "East Jordanians" and handing both East and West banks on a silver platter to their real champion - Bashar Assad!

The author fears (irrationally) that "Israel could forcibly kick out the Palestinians into Jordan and Egypt in a genocidal war and, in the process, destroy the Jordanian state as we know it today.", so how come Israel didn't do it already? Because Israel is wise enough to recognise that it NEEDS its ally "Jordan as we know it today" (and Egypt) to prevent the East-Bank of the Jordan river from falling in the hands of Syria, Russia and Iran.

#Yuyutsu

There you go again - attacking the messenger and ignoring the message.
Read the message and for once try to absorb and understand it.

Dear David,

I have read the message and understand it very well: serves the interests of some Saudis, serves the interests of the Southern-Syrians (who call themselves "Palestinians") - How? By destroying their hated states, Israel and Jordan, by letting these Southern-Syrians infiltrate their ranks then handing the whole region to Syria, Iran and Russia.

Hitler killed 6 million Jews - now some Saudis, Southern-Syrians and other collaborators conspire to kill another 6.8 Israeli Jews, including my family. Bottom line, this is a plot to murder my family in Israel: it is just a matter of time before your organisation, "Jordan is Palestine", will be exposed as a terrorist organisation!

Correction: in my rage about this conspiracy to kill my family, I inadvertently omitted the word "million". Obviously this Saudi conspiracy is to kill 6.8 MILLION Jews (not just 6.8 Jews).

#Yuyutsu

Rave on McDuff. You are a total waste of space.

Dear David,

Your country seems to be a total waste of space - how about dividing Syria between Jordan, Turkey, Lebanon and Iraq?

Actually, some of that land ought to be allocated for a free Kurdistan!