The Forum > Article Comments > The disgruntled former prime minister > Comments
The disgruntled former prime minister : Comments
By Binoy Kampmark, published 16/11/2018Attempting to maximise the effect of his deposition, Turnbull began a campaign of ennobling self-effacement and cleansing.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Page 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
-
- All
Posted by Shadow Minister, Saturday, 17 November 2018 1:28:14 PM
| |
Foxy,
Given the 6 years, Labor and the greens had to implement SSM but failed, then tried to block the plebiscite, the rank hypocrisy of the left whingers stinks to high heaven. Posted by Shadow Minister, Saturday, 17 November 2018 1:30:47 PM
| |
SM,
The history of same sex marriage in Australia includes its expressed prohibition by the Howard government in 2004. And, it was the Howard government that introduced the Marriage Amendment Act in Parliament, 27th May 2004. As for broken promises? Why only mention those of Labor? There's Howard's "core" and "non-core" and never ever GST. There's Tony Abbott's no new taxes, no cuts to education, no cuts to health, no cuts to the ABC or SBS, just to mention a few. The Abbott government then went on to make changes in all these areas. We have Malcolm Turnbull's promises of a first rate - less expensive - NBN - promise (what a joke that turned out to be) - and the same-sex marriage plebiscite 2016. And what a fiasco that turned out to be - and guess who abstained from the vote? Barnaby Joyce (Nationals) Tony Abbott (Libs) Andrew Hastie (Libs) Michael Sukkar (Libs) Kevin Andrews (Libs) Scott Morrison (Libs) George Christensen (LNP) Rick Wilson (Libs) Stuart (Libs) Bert van Maren (Libs) What about no votes? Bob Katter (Independent) Russell Broadbent (Libs) Keith Pitt (Nationals) David Littleproud (Nationals) Interesting isn't it. In any case - we can always find something to finger-point at in politics. But you prefer not to see that, and only see things from your one-eyed, rusted on political agenda. Posted by Foxy, Saturday, 17 November 2018 1:52:19 PM
| |
C'mon Foxy. Be fair. Howard didn't ban gay marriage. He just ensured that the marriage act dealt only with male-female couplings. And it was a bipartisan measure, it passed with Labor support. It was never illegal to get married to someone of the same sex, it is just that the government wouldn't register the relationship. They don't register relationships for heterosexuals either, unless they explicity want it registered, and registered or not, there is no difference between how all the important things are treated - children, property, estates between registered and non-registered relationships.
I don't think you are in a good position to criticise others for allegedly being politically rusted-on. You exhibit the same traits yourself. Posted by GrahamY, Saturday, 17 November 2018 2:23:39 PM
| |
Hi Graham,
Discussions on this forum are not about being fair. I don't think the fairness issue plays into them. Because it would not be fair to ask some, what we're not willing to ask of others who post here. Anyway, I tend to base my posts on facts as much as I am able, usually with links that I provide to back them up. And the link given below backs up the fact that the former Prime Minister John Howard did target gays. The article from the Sydney Morning Herald makes it quite clear that - "Gay couples will be banned from marrying or adopting children from overseas..." We're told that less than an hour after PM John Howard announced changes to the Marriage Act, the government rushed legislation enabling the changes into Parliament. Mr Howard said the Marriage Act would be changed to include the definition of marriage as the voluntarily entered into union of a man and a women to exclusion of all others. The laws prior to that did not define marriage. Mr Howard stated - "We've decided to insert this into the Marriage Act to make it very plain that is our view of a marriage and to also make it very plain that the definition of a marriage is something that should rest in the hands ultimately of the the Parliament of the nation." This Mr Howard stated to reporters. "It should not over time be subject to redefinition or change by courts, it is something that ought to be expressed through the elected representatives of the country." They also outlawed the recognition of same-sex marriages lawfully entered into in foreign jurisdictions and they prevented same sex couples from adopting children from overseas countries. They deliberately amended the Marriage Act to define marriage. The following link explains: http://www.smh.com.au/national/pm-targets-gays-in-marriage-law-20040528-gdj0cp.html Posted by Foxy, Saturday, 17 November 2018 4:28:03 PM
| |
Alan B.,
Thank You for your kind words. The art of reasoned, intelligent argument is a skill not easily acquired - you've got it in spades. Therefore receiving a compliment from you on my postings is very heart-warming and much appreciated. Posted by Foxy, Saturday, 17 November 2018 6:42:06 PM
|
Why is that those on the left feel the need to blow smoke up each other's backsides?