#Yuyutsu

In response to your numbered replies:

1. God forbid the words "Jews" and "Jewish State" are mentioned.
You cannot talk about what Israel "took in 1967" without talking about what Jordan "took in 1948" when it kicked out every single Jew living in the West Bank and Egypt did the same thing to every Jew living in Gaza.

These are not "Jewish legends" - they are facts that you do not want to acknowledge.

2. It was you who was urging a boycott to get Israel to return to the "good old borders and good old ways."

When I point out there were no good old borders and the good old ways involved the killing of Jews in massacre after massacre - you just bury your head in the sand again. Pathetic.

3. At least you acknowledge the error of your comments that there can be "good" and "bad" racism and discrimination. Well done.

#Geoff of Perth:

Have you emerged from hibernating under your rock of anonymity for the Australian summer?

Your comments are still as dumb as ever:

Comparing Israel's claims in the West Bank to " the territorial claims of invading German thieves to stolen territory in Poland" is laughable.

Israel's claims are based on legal rights vested in the Jewish people to reconstitute the Jewish National Home in the West Bank pursuant to article 6 of the Mandate for Palestine and article 80 of the United Nations Charter.

It is this settled international law that "gives the thieves in settlements within occupied Palestine/East Jerusalem such territorial rights"

The PLO, Hamas, Geoff of Perth and many other anonymous Jew-haters commenting on my articles don't like this international law thrown in their face - so choose to not respect or recognise those decisions and make the kind of stupid abusive claims as in your current post. Rejection will get you all nowhere - as events of the last 100 years have shown.

Dear David,

1. Though I have my personal views on the matter, I will not be diverted to discuss how true or otherwise those Jewish legends are. The topic is Israel, not Jews.

The poor behaviour of Jordan and Egypt towards Jews should indeed weigh on their conscience, but we aren't discussing here how to fix the Arabs' internal and moral problems, are we?

2. The good old borders and good old ways pertain to Israel and to Israel alone. Nothing to do with Arabs and their massacres of Jews - which is a complete red-herring. If you like to discuss how Arabs can repair their conscience, then better start a new topic.

3. All I acknowledged was that I was carried away by your question off the topic - it was my mistake and I hope not to repeat it.