With onlineopinion constantly publishing Singer's hate-filled rants denying the right of Palestinians to exist, surely it is beginning to tarnish onlineopinion too.

Why do you provide him a platform? Why must readers be subjected to his constant barrage of hate?

I counted 151 articles. Has any other author even come close to that many articles?

How many pro-Palestinian articles have been published compared to pro-Israeli? Why the discrepancy?

Can we take a breather from Singer and his de-humanizing Palestinians for a while?

I would endorse Dane's comment fully.

Why do we, in Australia, have to be subjected to pro-Israel, Anti-Palestinian political rants and raves on a weekly basis from a zealot who will tell any lie to advance the Imperial, Racist Jewish nation?

Ignoring Singer completely is one thing that readers of OLO can do. I do now.

I guess if I was a Palestinian I wouldn't comment on OLO and would see it acting all too often as a rollicking bastion of Israeli-American-Capitalist propaganda.

Dear David G.,

<<Why do we, in Australia, have to be subjected to pro-Israel, Anti-Palestinian political rants and raves on a weekly basis>>

Pro-Israel?? ??

The occupation of the West Bank and Eastern Jerusalem was the worst thing that ever happened to Israel. It destroys it from within and vacates it of any remaining moral grounds to exist.

Mr. Singer advocates the continuation of Israel's occupation, at least in part, hence he is Israel's enemy.

In doing so, he is also pro-Palestinian, because with this occupation, the Palestinians only need to sit and wait for Israel to collapse by itself.

As for this week's specific title, Israel should not care how those stupid so-called "Palestinians" define themselves, nor should it continue talking with Kerry - none of it is its business: it should simply withdraw from their cursed lands and build the big wall over its 1967 borders instead of where it stands now.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=295KeA1MTJc

The above video was secretly recorded at numerous US/Israeli High level policy meetings. Now we know why the Palestinians and Muslims are terrified

YBIGA scat are animal droppings. Scatman = crapman.

Henceforth we should all boycott David Singer's articles. Pass no comments and most importantly,do not read them. Do not feed the trolls.

#Arjay

I wonder why it has taken you so long to make your momentous decision - but I applaud it.

Hope your fellow Jew-haters come to the same conclusion.

David Singer
Let us examine this Jew hatred and weigh it against the Jewish States hatred of Muslims.
Is it not true that many jews believe that Muslims are no more then goats?

Is it not true that The Jewish state has built a very large fence, just like a goat farmer, to surround their Muslim stock? Is it also not true that the Jewish State has continuously denied that these Palestinians are a people at all?

You reside amongst us here in our post Christian secular society. Our values are of equality and liberty. They validate all and exclude none and you dare accuse us of Jew hating. You who weekly spit out this racial and religious defence of the Jewish states crimes. You don't live there, you live here and under our laws. Whilst we can acknowledge the frustrated errors of Palestinians, you weekly spit out this inhumane denial of an entire people.

And should we dare to question your singular narrative, we are to be accused of Jew hatred. The freedom we permit you to exercise defending your genocidal hatred, is the self same freedom which entitles us to call you to account.

Zionists like yourself, David, have destroyed the good name of the Jewish people. Good Jewish people are embarrassed and afraid of Zionists like yourself. Even in Israel today, Orthodox Jews are protesting the militant hatred of the Jewish state.

It is amazing that a people who have produced many of the greatest minds in virtually every field of human endeavour, over the last century, can have surrendered the running of the Jewish state to thugs.

Perhaps, it is to be expected. The one constant throughout 6,000 years of Jewish history is political incompetence

#Yebiga

You state:

"The freedom we permit you to exercise defending your genocidal hatred, is the self same freedom which entitles us to call you to account.

Could you please point to one sentence in any of my articles justifying your claim of "genocidal hatred"?

Can I make two suggestions:

1 Take Arjay's advice and don't read my articles or post Jew-hating comments to my articles which never attempt to discuss anything I raise in my articles - other than comments denigrating Jews and the Jewish State.

2. Change your name to Yebigot

David,
Don't think your spurious equivocations concerning the Palestinians fool anybody.
Whilst the wall stands, there can be no denying that supporters of the Jewish state believe Palestinians to be Goats. Your objectives are merely to build another enclosure.

You must take their land step by step, and as god ordered in Exodus, never enter into treaties with them for it would be bad for you.

And so it is that a great confusion beset the Jewish people misled by the zionist idolatry. A once great people now addicted to power and mednacity, misplaced their god and bathed in the blood of the innocent. What crime is now beyond them?

#Yebiga

The only goat present in this discourse is yourself.

Are you capable of comprehending and answering the following question I posed to you as a result of criticism you leveled at myself:

"The freedom we permit you to exercise defending your genocidal hatred, is the self same freedom which entitles us to call you to account.

Could you please point to one sentence in any of my articles justifying your claim of "genocidal hatred"?

Come on Yebigot - just one example.

There are 151 articles to pick from.

How, you ask are you promoting genocide?

I shall try to explain it to you with some simple examples.
Imagine someone defending Stalin's USSR and ignoring the purges
Or, NAZI germany and ignoring the treatment of jews.

Is it not evident that the Palestinians have have been shunted out of their homes and fences built around them? Is it not clear that daily Israeli military herd them like cattle.

So what would you call this ethnic cleansing?

David, you write about this issue as if it were a minor and legitimate dispute between equals. You think that as long as you use civil language with the air of reasonableness, the egregious truth will be obscured.

You know as well as we all know, your singular purpose is to engage us in reasoned discourse. For any discussion of the details of a solution legitimises Israel. And the one thing Israel desperately lacks is legitimacy.

#Yebiga

How thick are you?

I repeat - and will keep repeating until you answer:

"Are you capable of comprehending and answering the following question I posed to you as a result of criticism you leveled at myself:

"The freedom we permit you to exercise defending your genocidal hatred, is the self same freedom which entitles us to call you to account.

Could you please point to one sentence in any of my articles justifying your claim of "genocidal hatred"?

Come on Yebigot - just one example.

There are 151 articles to pick from."

Put up - or shut up.

David
I must apologise for my dimwittedness
But every time I read your posts I am convinced of their mendacity. I try to understand them, I really do, but I can't make head or tail of them. All I can see is that you want Israel to be seen in a good light.

Anyway, good luck and may god bless you and awaken both of us.

#Yebiga

Surely everyone should strive to be seen in a good light - even you.

Here is your chance.

What about an apology for accusing me of "genocidal hatred" without a shred of evidence to back up your claim?

To you I apologise - it was unfair
But as to Israel, I believe it applies and is well founded.

#Yebiga

I appreciate your apology which certainly puts you in a much better light.

Perhaps after you watch the following video - you will see Israel in a better
light.

http://www.prophecynewswatch.com/IsraelSeries/medicine.html

Israel is not perfect - but neither are a lot more countries around the world - yet no one seeks to consistently undermine and delegitimise their very existence.

David
Many like me will remain appalled by Isreal until it comes to some understanding with its neighbours. Isreal must not only defend itself against Muslim extremists it must equally fight the extremists in its own camp.

Your video link, for example, took me to a site obsessed with religious prophecy, end of days paranoia. This kind of thinking is deeply disturbing as it makes people ready to believe any crap. Politicians in both Isreal and Washington have evolved an entire foreign policy with the support of religious messianism to build up Islamic bogeyman and thereby achieve ends of sheer bloody mindedness in Afghanistan and Iraq.

These are sins of the gravest kind, which, if there be a just god, must condemn all those involved to eternal damnation

#Yebiga

There you go again!

No comment about the video or its contents - only another opportunity to bash Jews

"Many like me will remain appalled by Israel until it comes to some understanding with its neighbours"

Are you equally appalled by Syria, Lebanon, Hamas, the PLO, Islamic Jihad, and Saudi Arabia because they cannot come to some understanding with Israel?

Are you so threatened by the video that you have to use a red herring and comment about the site where it is located?

What are your views on the video? Deal with that issue.

Here is another video on another site
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-C3UYq-UxA&feature=youtu.be

Review this one and let me know your opinion.

David
I did watch the video. To be honest it reminded me of the propaganda ads routinely aired in soviet bloc countries back in the 1970s. Obviously, the technological outcomes are impressive. It is good to see the billions of dollars in US aid over the decades have not been entirely for military purposes.

I'm not sure what point you believe this makes.

The equivalence in treatment you ask for between Israel, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, etc is quite frankly bizarre considering the government in these countries is either hand picked by the US, or historically bastardised by imperial forces and in a state of suspended development.

Turkey maybe the only country in that region, who has not been historically bastardised and who conducts itself with an autonomy reflective of itself. Turkey is surrounded by numerous ethnic issues but manages to progress peacefully though them.

#Yebiga

You state:

"The equivalence in treatment you ask for between Israel, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, etc is quite frankly bizarre considering the government in these countries is either hand picked by the US, or historically bastardised by imperial forces and in a state of suspended development."

When will the bastards stop being bastards?

When will they stop their humanitarian assaults on each other as is currently occurring in Syria? Read the following and tell me what excuse can be given for what is going on there.

http://www.dailystar.com.lb/News/Middle-East/2014/Mar-11/249890-55-million-children-impacted-by-syria-conflict-un.ashx?utm_medium=email&utm_source=transactional&utm_campaign=Newsletter#axzz2vgyxBXAh

You state:

"Turkey maybe the only country in that region, who has not been historically bastardised and who conducts itself with an autonomy reflective of itself. Turkey is surrounded by numerous ethnic issues but manages to progress peacefully though them."

Tell that to the Kurds.

David
The Syrian conflict is a Civil War - no more need or should be said.
The Turkish Kurd problem whilst real and violent has currently subsided. In the long term, the Kurds spread over several neighboring countries is a unique issue which presents greater difficulties than those in Palestine.

Ethnicity is a scourge.

I cannot see how an intelligent well educated Jewish people can insist on perpetuating this artificial construct. It is true, I am more forgiving of Islamic countries but as you know too well, they are not as well educated, as developed or technologically capable. I am also for the same reason more forgiving of Papua New Guinea tribal brutality but less forgiving of Australian outrage.

You consistently practice false equivocation which you're way too smart for it to be unwitting. So lets be frank, you and enough Jews are extremely nationalistic and therefore pursue on behalf of and for Israel policies and discourses which are promote this patriotism.

I and I believe mankind's history cries that we are best served by relinquishing these distinctions. They retard us and corrupt us. I am equally offended by Australian or American jingoism.

It amazes me that a people who remain the most glaring victims, the holocaust, to this patriotic nonsense and ethnic garbage, now pursue the self same destructive inhumane ideology.

Dear Yebiga,

You should look at nationalism/patriotism as a disease, a hereditary infection. Babies suck it with their mother's milk and it unconsciously becomes attached to one's sweetest childhood memories, which nobody likes to give up. Many also come to believe that without it their parents would stop loving them and indeed for some that is the case, where parents may see them as traitors and disown them.

I remember as a child hearing a nationalistic song, sang by an inspiring wonderful choir, that includes the words "far away is Homeland/Mother, sighing, grunting, dripping blood", then I innocently asked my father: "Daddy, why is Mom bleeding?"

Therefore please have compassion rather than vengeance and seek to heal rather than chastise the afflicted.