To #Rhys Jones

You state:
"The idea that as long as a nation does some good things, no one should criticise the bad things they do, does not make any sense to me at least."

You are entitled to criticise - but your motives and intent go far deeper as expressed by you in the following remark:

"Your religious beliefs do not give you a right to take someone elses land. Using it to Justify stealing someone elses land is the same as a fundamentalist Muslim saying their religion justifies killing infidels.

Your bizzare fantasy that you have been given great tracts of land by your imaginary god are about as reasonable as the 20th century German belief that they were a superior race and should therefore control the world. Look where that led.
Posted by Rhys Jones, Friday, 7 December 2012 5:00:24 PM"

No mention of:
(i) the defeat of the 400 years old Ottoman Empire in World War 1 and the allocation of 99.99% of the conquered Ottoman territory for Arab self determination and just 0.01% for Jewish self determination
(ii) The unanimous endorsement of that arrangement by every member state of the League of Nations with the creation of the Mandate for Palestine.
(iii) The 1937 Peel Partition Plan and the 1947 UN Partition Plan recommending a Jewish State and an Arab state. How come Peel, no member State in the League of Nations and the United Nations were totally ignorant of the fact that the land had been stolen by the Jews as you smugly proclaim in your four line unsubstantiated throw away?

You are a Jew hater trying to masquerade as some kind of reasonable guy who just wants to criticise Israeli policies - not demonise or delegitimize the Jews who make up the majority of its population.

Sorry - I don't believe you.

To #Candide

You are no better in your use of the term "the Orthodox leeches on Israeli society."

Are you prepared to withdraw that remark and also tell Rhys Jones off for the above remarks he made on 7 December 2012?

This is real nutcase territory. To a comment by Rhys Jones which is in effect a statement that nobody - not Germans and not Jews - has any valid claim to exceptional genetic entitlement beyond the norm, the Israel agent David Singer responds with a list of total irrelevancies that purport to show that Jews do in fact have special, exceptional, entitlement invented by colonialists and that Rhys Jones denying it is doing so from deeper motives of . . . .(wait for it). . . . . antiSemitism.

There most definitely needs to be a public debate over whether Australia should or should not continue to give the slightest respect to a racist experiment even more squalid than Apartheid South Africa (in which the Boer overlords at least belonged to the country even though they claimed they didn't have to share it).

Rhys Jones,

Yes, Nazi Germany was the most technologically advanced nation in Europe and in advance of the US in many areas of engineering and far ahead of the UK. Nazi Germany produced the first synthetic antibiotics---sulfa drugs and the ubiquitous "jerry can". An equally nasty regime, the Soviet Union, pioneered space exploration.

The Trollsinger is grasping at straws.

David Singer,

No critic of Israel could possibly wish that you were banned.

Russell Walton

Emperor Julian, again I beseech you to not engage with the Singer. It is such a waste of time. He is a fanatic and he has no interest in anything that doesn't advance the imperial Israeli cause.

Singer has a number of puppets on his strings. He plays them, one against the other, week by week. And all the time he is promoting the right of Israel to develop a racist, apartheid nation, a nuclear-armed one, one plonked right in the middle of a Muslim region.

We who think should get rid of the Singer. He is mischievous and duplicitous. His agenda is disgusting. And while he tells us of the glories of Israel, Israel is committing war crimes and atrocities and stealing land which belongs to the Palestinians, etc.

Emperor and others who are playing Singer's game, please don't. He needs to be sent to Coventry where he can't further undermine human values, the few that are left.

David G,

I disagree, silence is complicity, and I also don't like to be characterised as a "puppet", Singer is an incompetent propagandist, that should be obvious. If you can't participate in the debate that's your problem.

please lets not talk of censure..respect*

i iike peter..he has passion..
however we might think..it to be..miss-directed..
he really holds his heart on his sleeve..and i can respect that.

he also replies peoples posts
[i respect that]

he puts in real extra effort..to educate
[i appreciate that]

ok he avoids many points
thats his right

he maybe..right in so many..minutia..little detail
yet still..miss the big picture..[or we are]..but were talkinmg[thats great]

you see the script was written..differently..
by now [peter may not even know..but..bombs were supposed to be doing their thing

thursday was to be the lay down..mizare
the website thing [done via a captured email/intercept]..was to be the cream..on top

we must expect..a little shell shock..
or at least sympathy

this nice guy..has just been gutted..
by the state he clearly loves..and the world yearns to know

oh..the rejoicing when..
ALL*..the descendants of abraham..unite..in brotherly loving peace..unite with one heart..the messiahs return..[

once we LET sharon..mediate
for your beloved israel...on.the statehood's achievements..as well as her sins]

ps i..know somewhere in
there is 3 more points

dont stop being PROUD..our people
have much to be proud of

[but also visa versa]..
but heck..ONLY..god is..perfect
and were only human.

lets exchange facts..
so that all..between..us here*..at least..is truth*

bless your passion..my brother
for what is salt..that has lost its taste