The Forum > Article Comments > Nanny state threatens nanny with naughty corner > Comments
Nanny state threatens nanny with naughty corner : Comments
By Mark Christensen, published 15/4/2011Bureaucratising punishment of children in childcare centres will destroy trust, autonomy and damage the system.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- Page 7
- 8
-
- All
People who go on about 'having it all' are delusional. It is possible to have it all but only in a superficial sense and the journey is fraught with exhaustion and unrealistic expectations. But to each his/her own.
"The institutionalisation of infants en masse is a dubious distinction indicative of a society that places the pursuit of excess way above the emotional and developmental well-being of its most vulnerable citizens."
Well said Poirot. I have used child care part time for a couple of years but spent most of my children's early years at home. It has been worthwhile.
I never had any trouble getting back into the workforce - one just has to start over to some extent - that is one of the trade-offs and that is okay. Why do people think life has to always provide them with exactly what they want at all times. Start your own business.
The idea that women become unemployable after raising kids is something myself and many friends and acquaintances have never experienced. It is more myth than reality. The proliferation of home computers and access to information means women are less apt to lose their skills.
I have many rigorous discussions with other women about the implications and long term effects of child care - mainly started by them in an attempt to justify their choices. Just saying you were a stay-at-home is enough to spur others to launch into a self-fulfilling ethical debate about the benefits of child care and the rights of women.
It is human nature to justify one's own actions. Studies of child care reveal the benefits of child care tend to apply in dysfunctional family situations and where incomes are lower and where good child care can provide a positive contrast.
The dreadful 'Working Families' has become so ingrained and necessary for some that the idea of staying at home is not seen as a viable alternative even if many women would choose that option.