When Dr. Keith Suter had an interview with Sunrise on Wednesday 4th July about Muslim doctors, Glasgow attack in UK and Dr. Haneef, he said he was surprised why doctors have chosen the option of attack in STREETS rather than using their profession and qualification. He has indirectly said that if they would use their profession they would be able to kill more people at hospitals.
An Australian Muslim cleric has complained that Channel 7 broadcast was indirectly instructing terrorists.
Sheikh Haron in his letter to Mr. Damian Bugg 'DPP' says: " What has been broadcasted was like this story for example: A bomb explodes in a quiet train station like Seven Hills, next day someone in TV says: It's strange, I don't understand why they have not chosen Town Hall train station? Why they have not exploded Town Hall or Central station to be able to kill more people?"
Sheikh Haron also says such a broadcasted material will result in breaking the trust between doctors and patients and Australians will fear to visit a Muslim doctor. They will prefer to avoid treatment by a Muslim doctor than to be killed by the poisoning injection of a Muslim doctor.
He finally says: " at this time that the case of Dr. Mohammad Haneef is almost closed, it is expected from Australian government to show that there is no difference between Muslims and Non Muslims when it comes to breaking the law, to prove that there is no discrimination about Anti terrorism law, and all people will face charges if they commit any kind of terrorist acts whether they are Muslims or Non Muslims, whether it is a Mosque or a Church, an Islamic Radio station or Channel 7 , whether he is Dr. Mohammad Haneef from India or Dr. Keith Suter from Sunrise.
Now there are few questions:
1. Do you think Channel 7 will be charged?
2. Has Sunrise has instructed terrorists?
3. Channel 7 has right to warn Australians to be careful when they visit a Muslim doctor for safety?

Well I think Sunrise is right to warn Australian patients about Muslim doctors. I prefer Non Muslim doctor if I fear.
Sunrise is not terrorist, Sheikh Haron is wrong. Am I right? lol

Where can we find a script of what Dr Keith Suter has said?

Philo you can purchase it from Channel 7

Yeah Philo you can get it from Sunrise, if they don't give it to you don't worry I have a copy if you need one !

Shiekh Haron seems to be getting taking out of contex.
I think he was trying to saying the broad sense a Dr could do more harm in his field of work than doing something he is not trained for.
After having said that the Australian public approve of the way the Federal Police handled the matter of the Gold Coast Dr.
That has been established through many polls and is the reason Rudds not pushing it.
The Federal Police have far more information than we do and I for one are happy to leave protecting Australia up to them.
This does not mean that in this country the Sheikh is not entiled to respond and make a point from what the Dr said either.

Sunrise have never been ones to take much resonsibilty for what they regually misinform the public about.
On no less than three ocashions - Coshieit -
has told his listeners the high price of meat in Australia has nothing to do with live exports?
I couldnt believe my ears or that somebody could just mouth off on national Tv about something they clearly had zero knowledge of.

So we contacted the producer and requested a invitation to debate that or a retraction from 7.
Its time the public woke up to the political overtures of the media.

Just another example of Sunrise and others being totally irresposible and very arrogant.

And for goodness sake sack the guy who picks the bands that go on that show early AM.
A very poor example for our kids before they leave for school.
A nightmere for the rest of us

Hi People Against Live Exports ....
I like your comments I agree except that part your saying "Sheikh Haron seems to be getting taking out of contex"
You say Dr Suter was trying to say a Dr could do MORE HARM IN HIS FIELD OF WORK than doing something he is not trained for.
What Sheikh Haron says about Dr Suter's sentence is exactly same as your sentence, but you two are expressing same thing by different words. Both sentences will result in instructing terrorists and showing a bad image for Muslim doctors.

You are right regarding an invitation to debate that or a retraction from channel 7.
I think sunrise should move quickly before is too late. If Muslims think they have been insulted by National TV they might protest or even more...

P Dox
Point Taken. I agree. I didnt actually see the interview so was just guessing.
Since Sunrise are so interested in Muslim affairs we would also like to invite the Federal Government to join us in that debate.

Meat Prices In Australia- and who? is responsible for the laws which allows both kosha and Halal[ Islamic slaughter in Australia "without! pre stunning the Animals.?"

The last time I looked AQIS had the power to over ride our laws if it had anything to do with Religion.
I am sure considering its a five billion dollar industry the Federal and State Governments must have some interest in it.

Umm and just before a federal election.

So if AQIS have the powers to allow ritual slaughter of Animals HERE IN AUSTRALIA- isnt AQIS The Federal Government.??

And all this time we blamed the Muslims.
Just for the record Coshei to get on TV and misinform the public about live exports not pushing the price of meat up is pretty irresponsible.

I have been savage in my attack on AFIC whom I used to work with for a number of years for not standing up to these extreme Islamic barbaric requirents.[ Kosha too being the most cruel of all!
After saying that WE ALL KNOW its the Federal Government and I DONT HEAR RUDD Objecting either.

Shame on the lot of them.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2007/08/03/1995804.htm

Thanks for your comment P Dox

Hi People Against Live Exports & Intensive Farming

I don't know why I cant stop repeating a part of your comments
I was thinking to myself I was attracted to that like a poem. I admire the way you think and the way you write. I like to repeat it here for others, and on behalf of the writer , I dedicate this poetry to Sunrise !

Its time the public woke up
to the political overtures
of the Media

And for goodness sake sack
the guy who picks the bands
that go on that show
early AM

A very poor example for our kids
before they leave for school
A nightmere
for the rest of us

P Doz

Thanks for you comments.

I must addmitt not many people like the way I think becuase its normally too confronting. They say Oh no not those people again going on about Animal Welfare.

If I had my time again I would have called it People Against diseases brought on by intensive farming - or stuff the animals what about our health.
Sunrise take on many issues for better causes.

I am just wondering why Koshie doesnt protest about the millions of diseases being spread by poultry pigs and the like being pumped with anti biotics everyday to try to curb diseases caused through crowding animals in such small pens they cant spread a wing or turn their heads or stand up the whole of their miserable lives.

The question of live Animal exports was on Sunrise once when they had somebody from PETA in America on Video.
Wonder why America Koshie?

The truth about Muslim~s my friend is this-
There is no such thing as a Australian Muslim because there is only one Allah.
Trust me I know being the only person in this country to hold a MOU with Muslim leaders for five years.

The poor buggers are stuck betwen a rock and a hard place. Just imagine being trapped between Howard and Allah.

Ah but alas! perhaps a small donation from the extreme Muslims out of the five billion dollar Halal trade.

Who cares if Australia is turned into A Halal Ritual slaughter country at those rates.

After all its not like Australia has much in the way of Animal Welfare so lets bring it down even lower.

The Government know this as well which is why they are looking into giving Kosha and Muslim people the right to carry out ritual slaughters in Australia.

So Koshie does this interest you? Or do you have check with the Live exporters Mr Murdoch and Mr Packer.

Could it be that is the reason Sunrise have been SO QUIET on the 60 Minute report?
Just asking

Hi People Against Live Exports ....

You said you have contacted the producer of Sunrise for invitation to debate that or retraction from 7 , have you recieved any reply from Channel 7? Any news? :)

I've got hot news! I've got the copy of an open letter from Sheikh Haron to Prime Minister John Howard which has been sent on 16th August 2007. It is interesting ... I think its better I explain about it in a new discussion thread, what do you think? :)

Hi P Dox.

No, No News.

Actually that was a year ago.

They did have a lady from PETA which is an American Group on a few months later so I dont know if Coshie did that on purpose or perhaps his manager.
Its possibly it was no conection but as we wrote them a fair bit I tend to think it was pay back.

He was PURPOSELY rude as far as I am concerned and went on bagging her after she left.

He at NO time acknowledged that she was trying to improve Animal Welfare OR that Animals mattered.

"They could do so much!"- but no they turn a blind eye because of commercial interests connected to many media owners and also advertisers.

Its a no go zone.

Ever tried calling a talkback radio to speak about Animal Welfare- be it live exports or intensive farming.?

Dont bother- its SO corrupt its shameful.

Its worse because every time there is a political problem regarding animal welfare you hear suddenly all these dam announcers MISINFORMING the public. Suddenly they are all experts.

Try getting on a show to challange one of them about what they just said!

We have written to the Mininsters of Communication and many stations asking them NOT to continue their little tricks and lies!

Coshie certainly did not bring up the price of meat and go anywhere near the subject of asking why we say live exports are putting the price of meat through the roof for Aussie familys.
He KNEW PETA supported veggie groups and I suspect thats why he picked them.

Its probably just as well because it takes somebody in the meat industry to explain that in preference to Animal Welfare groups to be honest.
No they WONT touch it. Did you hear any of them complaing about Amada Vanstones interests in the cruel piggeries where these animals cant stand lie down turn.
Now to answer you question about your new thread
Are you going to post the letter he wrote to JH?
I will go look now.
See you on lin