Whenever the facts don't suit what Paul rooly-troolly wants to be true, he unleashes in inner 10 yr old.

Isn't that better than being a smarty and
joining the Nazi party? (smile).

They're the only options - acting like a 10 yr old or being a Nazi? Methinks that in the adult world there are a few other possibilities.

mhaze,

I'm so glad that you recognize that.
Having a sense of humour of course helps.

mhaze,

Not even you should fall for another load of clap trap from the Forum's leading liar when it comes to all things Aboriginal. You say you are waiting for the publication of the evidence in a unnamed, unpublished book, by a mystery author, Proud Boy Jose' claims it might be on its way. Well its been shown many times here that Jose' simply lies about Aboriginals to suit his racists narrative. This "book" claim is probably, or possibly, just another one of Jose's lies. Name the book, name the author!

Paul,

Book or no book, the information is already out there that there was a significant migration from the sub-continent into Australia's north round 2000BC and that these new immigrants had a significant effect on the lifestyles and culture of the Carpenterians. See the references I offered to SR.

The issue is that SR, unable to argue against the known migration, zeroed in on one aspect of Josephus' claims - that the immigrants, already known to have come from India, were from a specific part of India ie the Sentinelese. That might to true, false or disputed and its that aspect that I'm prepared to wait on. But it doesn't change the central fact that the so-called First Peoples of Carpentaria were, at the very least, heavily influenced by the immigrants of the 2000BC migration.

Whether they came from Bay of Bengal or some other part of India, is a mere historic curiosity, as is whether they came directly or via some island hopping migration. But to try to avoid facing the fact that a migration occurred, SR chose to try to discredit one minor part of that story.

There is a world of new information that is likely coming down the pipe on the mtDNA of various aboriginal migrations over the millennia and how various first peoples were pushed out by new 'first peoples', none of which is going to be welcomed.