The Forum > Article Comments > Still not sorry!? > Comments
Still not sorry!? : Comments
By Barbara Hocking, published 22/11/2007The federal government's recent policies on native title are a return to colonial practices.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- Page 3
- 4
-
- All
The entire aboriginal discussion is just so much baloney.
Posted by citizen, Friday, 23 November 2007 3:30:13 PM
| |
Yes, the history of the Australian government and Australia's indigenous peoples is not a pretty one. However, there are also some positive steps. For example, in a recent post ( http://indigenousissuestoday.blogspot.com/2007/11/native-title-claims-and-australian.html ) on the Indigenous Issues Today blog, there is an article on how the Native title process is having some positive effects.
Posted by flashgordon, Saturday, 24 November 2007 9:00:40 AM
| |
“human rights of indigenous peoples” should be the same as the human rights of every other person living under the banner of the nation.
Anything else is “racism” by another name. Either way, anything which divides and applies differentials of rights to people by way of race, class, gender, sexual persuasion or any other private choice, is corrupt and morally reprehensible. “Captain Cook had disobeyed his Royal Instructions” It was over 200 years ago, it has nothing to do with how people are treated today. Get over it! As has been previously pointed out, endemic child neglect and abuse is the sort of behaviour which a "responsible" government cannot ignore. When such endemic abuse and neglect is discovered, we and the children should thank our selves we have a (federal coalition) government with the moral fortitude to do something, unlike the (socialist state) government in Darwin. Posted by Col Rouge, Saturday, 24 November 2007 11:06:07 AM
| |
Col ,
Are you saying that it was quite ok for Howard and the Nationals to exclude Aboriginal People in the NT from the application of the Racial Discrimination Act in the implimentation of the Intervention by suspending it's provisions ? Downer thought it would net a few votes - but admitted it didn't work . For me I'm glad they went out on their ear . It took him 11 years too long to say "symbols are important " for Aboriginal People. My guess is he had his views well and truly set by the Nationals and the National Farmers Federation from Mabo on. And just as they are always trying to limit farm workers wage increases they continue to white - ant Native Title Rights . Their indifference and ignorance was appalling and another black- armband chapter in the book of Aboriginal Australia . We look forward with hope however for the future . Posted by kartiya jim, Tuesday, 27 November 2007 11:12:23 PM
| |
I often read the posts on this site, but have never actually posted before. But I would like to share a story with you.
My mother was born to an Aboriginal woman and a white-Australian man. As such she is black but is not as dark as her family. For the government, this meant that she met all the criteria for assimiliation under the 'White Australia' policy. Mum lived on a farm, in a timber house with both her parents and her two younger sisters. She was loved, cared for, and had a very happy life. In early 1966, at the young age of six, two white men pulled up in ute and took my mum. All she can remember of this day was being completely terrified of the two strange men and her mother screaming and crying. Her father was not home at the time. She was only allowed to take her doll, nothing else. Mum was taken to live with a foster family that lived in a rural town where she was the only Aboriginal person. She was treated like a slave, and was sexually abused on pretty much a daily basis by her foster father until she was finally able to escape at the age of 16. She was also forced to leave school after primary school, because her family wanted her to work in their corner store and told her that an education was wasted on a black girl. She was not allowed to talk about her life before and was forbidden from trying to find her mother. But she never forgot who she was and remembered her mothers name. Thankfully, years later she was able to find her mum and they were reunited when she was 17. Post cont. below. Posted by CoogeeGal, Friday, 30 November 2007 2:10:31 PM
| |
Post cont. from above.
Mum is now 47, and is still haunted by those years. She has built a wonderful life for herself and has a beautiful family, and every day she amazes me with the strong women that she has become. It frustrates me when people talk about these things happened in the past. This happened to people who are alive now. How can we pretend that this isn't an issue? And don't try to tell me that the government thought that what they were doing was right. That is a load of rubbish. This happened because Aboriginal people where considered second class citizens (which is reflected by the fact that they weren't included under the consitution until 1967 and where once classified under the flora and fauna act)and white Australia wanted nothing to do with them. No one will ever convince me that what happened to my mum was the right thing. This story can be told by hundreds of Aboriginal people across this country. Some have been stong enough to be able to move on with their lives, but can we really be blame those that aren't as strong and struggle in life today? An apology by the government and the Australian people is not about accepting resposibility, its about admitting that what happened in the past was wrong. When I talk about this issue to my non-Aboriginal friends, I always say to them 'If I told you my grandmother died, or that I had found out my fiance was cheating on me.....what would you say?'. Without a doubt, they always respond with 'I'm so sorry' or 'Im sorry to hear that'. They aren't taking responsibility for what happened but are expressing their understanding of an awful situation. I'm very greatful that I knew both by mother and my grandmother growing up, a lot of Aboriginal people today didn't have the same opportunity. Posted by CoogeeGal, Friday, 30 November 2007 2:11:03 PM
|