The Forum > Article Comments > Crunch time for Trump on Judea and Samaria (West Bank) > Comments
Crunch time for Trump on Judea and Samaria (West Bank) : Comments
By David Singer, published 14/11/2025With Israel rejecting a Palestinian state and Saudi Arabia demanding one, Trump may turn to a revived Saudi proposal that redraws borders without moving a single resident.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- Page 2
-
- All


#Before around 800AD, there were neither Muslims nor Jews in existence: their respective ancestors were #Judeans#.
Judeans ARE Jews, and always were. Yours is a pedantic argument; but everyone living in Judea was not a Jew of course. Jews who were, identified as such.
#Some Judeans migrated to Europe and some remained in Israel.#
There were always coming and goings over millennia.
You failed to mention the migration into Modern day Iran. Parthian Empire. That was politically significant during Rebellion against Rome over a couple of Centuries.
http://www.bu.edu/mzank/Jerusalem/p/period2-2-1.htm
This publication does a job on the ancient history of the Jews.
Read it, and get back to me.
The Roman Empire period was the moulding of the Jews towards modernity as like the rest of the West, it was a part of the Roman Empire. Significant.
Fear not, the Jews will be around awhile yet to come, I feel confident with that statement.
I wonder will they outlive Christianity and Islam.
I think Islam will eventually burn itself out; it’s anti Human.