this one of the most dreamy idea to keep floating for a solution. it has all of history agin it

1 1969 black September PLO tried to kill the the king

2 when Jorden had the control of the west bank they did nothing for the population

3 this is just a pretext for annexation of the west bank and pushing Palestinians out

bad idea

what he said

#Ben

Your claim that the Hashemite Kingdom of Palestine solution "has all the history agin (sic) it" is not borne out by the following facts:

1.Such a solution actually existed between 1948 and 1967 when the West Bank Arabs were given Jordanian citizenship and elected their own representatives to the Jordanian parliament. Their Jordanian citizenship was not withdrawn until 1988.

2. The PLO on its formation in 1964 did not claim regional sovereignty over the "West Bank of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan" or the "Gaza Strip". Redrawing the existing international border between Israel and Jordan will once again restore this previous 1948-1967 scenario - leading hopefully to an end of 100 years of unresolved conflict between Arabs and Jews.

3. Had Jordan stayed out of the 1967 Six Day War - as Israel warned it to do - the 1948-1967 status quo in the West Bank existing at 6 June 1967 would probably still have been in existence today.

Welcome back again, Ben Gershon!

I fully agree...
but it is best not to reply to this infinite robotic series
- at least not to be the first to respond, because that places the title of the article on the forum's main page, exposing it for more to read.

Israel is being corroded and destroyed from within, and the seeds for that have been sewn in 1967.
The only chance for Israel to be able to heal itself is for it to abandon every square millimetre of the poisonous territories it took over at the time.

But why at Jordan's expense?
Why should Jordan be corroded and destroyed as well?

Anyone stepping on that cursed land is doomed!
Let it therefore be the crazy Jewish Messianic settlers and their Muslim-terrorist comrades who remain there and suffer the curse, not the innocent people of Israel and Jordan - let both fanatic clans fight there among themselves to their heart's content, may their strengths be equal so they kill each other to the last.
Then let no one take their place. Let that cursed land remain vacant forever.