Israel has a right to defend itself, but not to illegally acquire the ancestral land of also, the sons and daughters of Abraham.

So, 800 people were evicted from such an illegally acquired settlement? How many Palestinians have been evicted and ancestral homes bulldozed? Because they belonged to the wrong tribe?

It's not as if they had a choice as the M.E. is full of Chieftains and kings etc. Were they consulted as to whether or not they wanted to fight?

Now Mr Singer wants to evict them wholesale and dump them in Jordan? HKOP. And if successful open up new land for Israel to claim as the spoils of war?

Little wonder neither Biden nor the UN are interested. But will support a negotiated two state solution as they only solution with a snowflakes chance in hell of ending the pointless bloodshed!
Alan B.

"Now Mr Singer wants to evict them wholesale and dump them in Jordan? HKOP. And if successful open up new land for Israel to claim as the spoils of war?"

AlanB...That's not even close to what's being proposed, ya dill. Go back and read all the relevant posts to try to understand the proposal.

Not proposed but intended. And as plain as the nose on your dumber than dumb face, ya Dill! Israel has form on the acquisition of illegally obtained territory! It's what they do not what they say that counts!
Alan B.

Why it wont work

1 the Husni Family was driven out of their old kingdom and planted in Jorden by the British as a sop for fighting with Lowrance in WW1

2 in 69 Palestinians tried to knock off the the King .

3 At the time of the Caliphate when they captured a Jordanian pilot. The King himself was so enraged He led the raid when He was shown the cruelty

4 the branches of Islam and history makes this proposition a non starter

realising Mr. Singer needs to help find a solution to a complex problem .I Wish He would spend his good will working for an answer that is not dammed by history.

In that area of the world memories are long and unforgiving

Welcome back Ben Gershon and thank you for the contribution.

Indeed, this HKOP thing is just a plot against Jordan, which would never commit national suicide by accepting it.

As for:
«realising Mr. Singer needs to help find a solution to a complex problem»

You should be aware that there is no such "Mr. Singer".
It is an AI robot, bombarding us weekly with the same, probably an experiment by some major computer/online conglomerate to see how many of us get tricked to believe that it is a human, then try to improve its algorithm. Alternately it could have been planted here by anti-Jordan hackers.