The Forum > Article Comments > Why the execution of Myuran and Andrew matters > Comments
Why the execution of Myuran and Andrew matters : Comments
By Amit Tewari, published 7/5/2015But what of the attention they received? Was it morally consistent, in world so full of suffering, that we cared about two petty drug smugglers getting shot?
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
-
- All
That ended in 1950 when Sukarno crushed the United States of Indonesia and unilaterally declared that the other 15 States had decided to abolish themselves without a vote and had decided without a vote to become part of his Republic. It is shameful that Australia and the rest of the UN stood by and did nothing to refute the dictator's claims let alone help the people who were now effectively slaves.
As for the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Indonesia didn't 'ratifiy' it until 2006 so I doubt they are too serious about it. Don't forget that Saudi Arabia declared it was in violation of Sharia law and that Indonesia has imposed Sharia law on Aceh as a substitute for independence.
You seem to endorse the claim of sovereignty that Indonesia makes, you seem to be willing to accept that Indonesia has a right to kill between 100,000 to half a million people in West Papua, why?
West Papua was a Dutch colony until Australia and the General Assembly agreed to occupy and take over responsibility for it as a UN trust territory in September 1962; we then accepted the offer by Indonesia to administrate our trust territory and under our wise trusteeship hundreds of thousands of people have been killed, their Councils and other civil organisations disbanded and declared illegal, Australia deported its medical stidents to Indonesia three weeks after we allowed Indonesia to assume the administration.
What about our responsibility to those million Melanesian people? How are we fulfilling our obligations under article 76 of the UN Charter? Canberra decided to supported General Assembly res.1752 for the occupation of the colony which is a 'entitlement' we gave ourselves under article 85 part 1 of the UN Charter but we are meant to only do that in order to protect people's human rights under article 76 etc.
Why are you able to see that killing Myuran and Andrew is wrong, but are able to accept the Indonesian killing and repression of our neighbours?