JKJ You manage to be offensive, inaccurate and fanciful. All in one post. I was tempted to ignore your latest idiocies but no doubt further down the track you would accuse me, wrongly, of not answering your question for whatever offensive reason comes to your small mind on that particular day.

I have already suggested you go to the latest text on the issue, but if that is too big a task you might go to Richard Ackland's article in The Guardian on line:

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/nov/03/when-children-are-bashed-on-nauru-it-is-a-matter-for-australian-law-whatever-scott-morrison-says

You might even follow up the links Ackland provides. Then we might be free of your tiresome trolling on this issue.

bulla: By the way. Look up the Ayatollah's "Little Green Book." Definitely worth a read.
So what is wrong. How and who made original inhabitants of this land Christians and then exploited physically, mentally and wealth

It's obvious you didn't even attempt to look up "The Little Green Book."

Did you get my post about all non-Aboriginal peoples should remove themselves from Australia & give the land back to the Original Inhabitants & leave it in it's Original condition?

No houses, tinnies, welfare, education, rifles, fishing gear, Clothes (remember everyone was naked), cars, roads. Sound good to you. I have advocated that those Aboriginals who wish to live in in their Traditional Manner be given a Home Land where they can live in their Original State. Once in there they can never come out & no contact with Europeans is ever allowed.

Do you think that that would be a good idea, Bulla
Posted by Jayb, Tuesday, 2 December 2014 7:52:01 AM

In reply to above:

Your weird and stupid comments speaks of your mentality about others and of your type.
One has not to read about what you want them to nor to be guided by your stupid reasons.They did not ask for or have any benefits arising from invaders so called wealth or facilities created,if you so think .It is all their wealth of which they have been deprived of and secluded ,driven away to areas where these perpetrators and like of you do not want to live.Both the wars which are called world war in fact were European wars and ot is almost destined that because of the same beasts the next war is not very far.Stop bragging about what you have stated unless you can be one of them and live amongst them even for a day and then feel what it means to be robbed and seeing the robbers enjoying spoils.

James O'Neill

I am not going to be sent on an errand to construct your argument for you.

Links to left-wing newspapers prove nothing except your own failure to understand what you're talking about.

You need to PROVE what OBLIGATIONS as a matter of INTERNATIONAL LAW Australia is in breach of you lying fool, and you need to prove it IN HERE by reference to the ORIGINAL sources of those alleged obligations, not links to the absent authority of yabble-yarp that just happens to impress your intellectual dishonesty.

Prove it, or concede it. Stop answering by evasion.

bulla: It is all their wealth of which they have been deprived of and secluded ,driven away to areas where these perpetrators and like of you do not want to live

What wealth. Please explain. As far as I know. Aboriginals didn't use currency. They lived in the native bush without housing, clothing, hospitals, welfare. They had no metals of any description only wood & stone tools as did the Europeans some 8 thousand years ago.

I can't seem to fathom weather or not you want to go back to that era or you want the Europeans to leave but continue to provide all the advantages European Culture brought to the Australian Aboriginal. the Latter, I think.

James
For your information, I have argued refugee cases all over Australia for over 20 years: in Port Hedland, Darwin, Curtin, and Villawood detention centres, in Melbourne remand prison, in the Immigration Department, the Refugee Review Tribunal, briefed counsel and personally argued cases in the Federal and Full Federal Courts, and originated High Court leading case law. I have employed refugee lawyers and trained them in forensic persuasion in refugee and administrative law including former judiciary, former UNHCR case officers, and a staff member who later became a member of the Refugee Review Tribunal. I have acted as the Executive Director of the Refugee Council of Australia.

I have saved more refugees from death, torture, false imprisonment and human rights abuses, than you’ve had hot dinners.

Last year doing cases on Manus Island, specifically looking for breaches by Australia of Australia’s obligations in international law, I researched the question, all the way from the source in the UN Refugees Convention, through the Australian Migration Act, to the PNG legislation and policy, to the case law.

Unlike you, I happen to know what I’m talking about.

And you post me a link to the Guardian? WTF? Your referral to a journalist whose regurgitations you have gobbled down in your eagerness to re-vomit your foregone fabble-yarp onto the public eye only shows how pathetic is both your and their intellectual dishonesty.

Either cite the original sources of international law that you say the Australian government has breached, and show facts and reason why they have breached them, or admit you are wrong.

Sick'em, Jayb abd JKJ.