The Forum > Article Comments > Just what are we fighting for in Afghanistan? > Comments
Just what are we fighting for in Afghanistan? : Comments
By Gary Brown, published 9/10/2009The huge fraud in the Afghan presidential 'election' conclusively demonstrates the regime of Hamid Karzai has no credibility.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- Page 3
-
- All
In many ways the quality of reporting on the BBC and Al Jazeera seems to be better than the mainstream western corporate newsmedia. I exepct this would have been even more true of Aljazeera during Israel's invasion of Gaza as you write. On the other hand, as brutal and criminal as that invasion was, that was obviously not going to be a watershed as, for example the invasion of Iraq or 9/11 were.
In any case, Aljazeera's participation in the cover-up of 9/11, alongside all the Western newsmedia, has caused a vast amount of more harm to Arab speaking people than what good would have come from its reporting of Gaza.
It should be obvious by now that merely 'better' reporting is just not good enough. I believe that if the BBC, in particular, had told the whole truth about the Iraq war in 2003 they would have made it impossible for the British Government to participate in the invasion. And I believe that the same applies to Australia's ABC.
The ABC's lame pretence at being critical of the Iraq war is exmplified by Kerry O'Brien's lightweight interview of John Howard on 31 March 2003 at http://www.abc.net.au/7.30/content/2003/s821040.htm
Note, how Kerry O'Brien called the war an 'ethical war':
"At some point in the ethical war the coalition leaders may have to decide between two high-cost actions - and I don't say the phrase 'ethical war' in a sarcastic fashion ..."
O'Brien could have easily torn John Howard's case for war to shreds simply by putting to him the known facts, for example, about the WMD inspections that had been aborted not long before then and the plea by WMD inspectors to the coalition not to invade, but he chose not to, and so hundreds of thousands died.
The BBC's effort appeared little better from this distance and however much, if at all, Al Jazeera was an improvement upon the BBC, it is obvious that, as I mentioned above, by failing to report on the controversy over 9/11 Al Jazeera gave a free kick to the Coalition forces.