The Forum > Article Comments > A humbling responsibility; a remarkable opportunity > Comments
A humbling responsibility; a remarkable opportunity : Comments
By Harriet Riley, published 18/6/2009If our generation can hold back climate change we will have outstripped, and maybe even redeemed, all our forebears.
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
- 2
- 3
-
- All
She also suggests that the current fight against climate change is akin to World War II, requiring total mobilisation. A better analogy would be the Vietnam war - one that we have no real hope of winning and, years after its lost, will probably realise that the theorists were wrong and there was no need to fight it in the first place.
Riley also makes several references to the current intergalacial period we are in (the gap between two ice ages - often referred to as the Holocene)), which has gone on much longer than many of the previous intergalacials. No-one knows why it has and any attempt to forecast when it might end is pure speculation in the current state of knowledge. However, Riley characterises the period as humans emerging into Spring which they are turning into summer by deliberate climate change.
A better anology is emerging into summer which is slowly turning into spring. Climate in the holocene is characterised by a regular series of peaks and troughs in temperatures (there is a scholarly journal called Holocene which publishes stuff on this, and its not in dispute), and there is some evidence that the swings are getting weaker (that part is controversial). The climate models beloved by the AGW people are completely useless in explaining any of that stuff. Riley should not want to be remembered as the climate equivalent of the people who argued for continuing the Vietnam war.