The Forum > Article Comments > The impossibility of atheism > Comments
The impossibility of atheism : Comments
By Peter Sellick, published 29/1/2009The God that atheists do not believe in is not the God that Christians worship, but rather an idol of our own making or unmaking.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 41
- 42
- 43
- Page 44
- 45
- 46
- 47
- 48
- 49
- 50
-
- All
…
Atheism has donned many guises. A broad definition sees atheism, as a system of thought, in opposition to theism. Sometimes atheists were those, who did not worship the gods of their day. Early Christians were atheists to Romans. Earlier still, one could be called an atheist for being impious towards god. Both Democritus and Epicurus were labelled, “atheist”, not because they didn’t believe in the gods, rather their atomistic philosophy showed them to think/act “without” god. The privative a- in atheist signifies without.
Other atheists deny the very existence of god, absolutely. Here, Sells does not see the subtle difference between being against god and, being without god, by holding counter beliefs. How can an atheist be against something that does not exist?
What Sells sees as an affront to a spiritual entity, is, on closer examination, an attempt by atheists to argue an alternative hypothesis. In this skirmish, theists and atheists, participate in dissimilar ways. The theist plays the atheist-messenger, whereas the atheist plays the evidence.
Atheism is associated with materialism, in so-much-as materialists defer away from an extramundane explanation for the First Cause. Materialism in its primitive form sees matter, not god, as its own first cause. Today, we find a self-organising universe evident in the quantum cosmology and mathematics. At this juncture, we have a dispute between atheist materialism (and its modern extensions) and theist natural & supernatural pluralism.
Again, the atheist appeals to (testable) evidence, as uncovered by science and known to unbiased history. The theist maintains the supernatural is revealed via divine visitations and spiritually guided insights in concord with editorship of a priestly caste.
To the theist, god is ultimately unknowable: God is a mystery. To the atheist, the universe is ultimately knowable: The universe is a conundrum. The theist passively receives: The atheist proactively explores.
Oly.