The Forum > Article Comments > The financial crisis in context > Comments
The financial crisis in context : Comments
By Wendell Cox, published 12/12/2008The market system has produced far better lives than we ever had before but we must correct the causes of the financial collapse.
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
The idea that the problem could be avoided by 'wise' regulation ignores the fact that it was government policy that caused the problem in the first place. Who shall guard the guards?
Ultimately, the 'blame the market' schools of thought are assuming that we can make real wealth out of thin air, without negative consequences, by having government inflate the money supply. That is what is really in issue here.
But of course we can't, because reality eventually kicks in. All government can really do is re-distribute: taking money from A and giving it to B. When the whole charade collapses under the weight of its own folly, people, not understanding how they were ripped off, blame "capitalism". But no advocate of capitalism ever claimed it can make bread from stones (apart from Keynes that is).
But there is also a deeper flaw in the idea of wise regulation. The whole point of economic activity is to try to bring about an improvement. The problem facing everyone is, the original economic problem is, how?
If government already presumptively knew the answer, there would be no need for private action of any kind, for private property, or for human freedom. We could just vest total power and all resources in government, and enjoy the optimal society. But the presumption of a well of superior wisdom in government is simply not reality-based.
Total government control over the economy leads to immediate collapse and mass starvation; but governments don't become magically more capable when it comes to partial control. The more and more we approach the state of governmental control of the economy, the more unsustainable, destructive and anti-social are the necessary consequences, however well-intended.