The Forum > Article Comments > What is a feminist? > Comments
What is a feminist? : Comments
By Cireena Simcox, published 25/1/2007A feminist is not a woman with hairy armpits and a chip on her shoulder.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- Page 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- ...
- 29
- 30
- 31
-
- All
It is feminists who argued themselves into the position that gender difference made women inferior. They did so by accepting the idea that our humanity is contingent and that we only become human through an act of creating who we are through our own reason and will.
Since the female role was seen to be more based on the emotions rather than reason, and since women had less formal economic and political power, feminists then thought that women were less human as things stood.
Hence the determination to believe that traditional gender qualities and roles were oppressive social constructs which could be overturned.
My view is that feminists were wrong to accept the initial assumption about what makes us human. They were wrong to see our humanity as being contingent on acts of power or on an autonomous reason unimpeded by biology or the emotions.
What if, for instance, our particular loves and attachments helped to define our humanity? Then men and women could be distinct in their gender qualities and social roles, but still consider themselves to be equal in their human status and their participation in the essential human experiences.
FrankGol, it's inadequate to dismiss a complaint about a lost generation as "masculine sour grapes". Something like 30 to 40% of tertiary educated women have ended up childless. That adds up to a lot of feminine misery. We ought to care about such things as they are what really matter most to people and cut most deeply at a personal level.