The Forum > Article Comments > The History Wars: now for the hard part! > Comments
The History Wars: now for the hard part! : Comments
By Mervyn Bendle, published 23/8/2006Australia desperately needs to promote a unifying sense of national identity.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Page 4
-
- All
One particular character in mind was Midgerecoo, who was father of Yagan, the youngster who after escaping from Carnac Island out from Fremantle, where he was held for not obeying the new law of the land, but was never captured again and finally shot by a farm lad.
However, while on Carnac, with two other native prisoners and a military guard, they were also accompanied by Robert Lyon, an enigmatic figure in early colonial history, who while Yagan was almost a year on the run, wrote an article about the young native, praising him to the point for his appearance, his friendliness and his ability to learn English, that Dr CT Stannage in his New history of Western Australia writes how Yagan achieved lasting fame as an outlaw and patriot.
There is a very different story about Yagan's father, Midgericoo, who was shot outside the gates of the Perth military barracks before what is said to have been an audience of both whites and blacks. Midgericoo was executed as the leader of a group who had ambushed and killed two white settlers as a reprisal for the death of Yagan's brother Domjun who was shot while breaking into a Fremantle store.
Now as the books were written under supervision for an elective as part of a post-grad in Social Science, and expected to be read by a public, there were parts of the thesis which had to be toned down. And it is so interesting as other historians will agree, that the tendency while writing, is to treat whom we might call the invaders more harshly than the invaded.
Were the truth lies, as Socrates might say, it lies deep down in our thoughts, or in our consciences.