The Forum > Article Comments > A human rights model that does not discriminate should underpin voluntary assisted dying legislation > Comments
A human rights model that does not discriminate should underpin voluntary assisted dying legislation : Comments
By David Swanton, published 5/5/2023If a person is suffering, but according to doctors is not ‘sick enough’ or has the wrong sort of illness, then bad luck. They must suffer as they would be ineligible for VAD.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- Page 2
- 3
-
- All
I can understand that most people want to be protected against murder (among other things), but even then, why particularly choose the state to be one's protector? this is not a free choice, this is a case of having no choice at all.
Suppose the state observed and therefore assumed that most people sought its protection, then why wouldn't it do the decent thing and make that the default while allowing people to opt out of its protection? The answer is that the state does not do so because it is not a decent body, because its whole existence came about by force and not by the will of the people, its victims.
It is not that I support murder, not even VAD, but had we been able to tell the state in advance, "Thanks for your offer of protection, but no thanks, I do not seek your protection against being murdered, so I release you of all responsibility and if I happen to be murdered then that would be none of your business.", then this whole discussion of VAD would have not been necessary to begin with!