The Forum > Article Comments > Religious wars > Comments
Religious wars : Comments
By Peter Bowden, published 28/2/2019Cardinal George Pell has been found guilty. Frank Brennan, a Jesuit priest, has raised the question of whether the jury reached the correct verdict.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- Page 5
- 6
- 7
-
- All
It demands that that twelve citizens reason guilt or innocence purely on the evidence presented in court.
That way of functioning is hopelessly outdated, stemming from an era well before the overwhelming impact of today's media.
Practically, our jurors seem to be selected from a supply of people who are probably not truly representative of the accused peers' socio-economic culture.
An amount of personal bias existed within juries in which I sat - some jurors were influenced by the appearance, manner of speech, or attitude of witnesses, particularly police who often portray an arrogant demeanour. It took considerable arguing accompanied by hostility to convince fellow jurors to act ONLY on the evidence.
But with these faults, it is the only system we have, other than the defence's ability to request a judge-only hearing.