The National Forum   Donate   Your Account   On Line Opinion   Forum   Blogs   Polling   About   
The Forum - On Line Opinion's article discussion area



Syndicate
RSS/XML


RSS 2.0

Main Articles General

Sign In      Register

The Forum > Article Comments > Australians and Turks remember Gallipoli > Comments

Australians and Turks remember Gallipoli : Comments

By Alice Aslan, published 24/4/2015

The seeds of two unique nations were sown during the battle of Gallipoli: Turkey with the disintegration of the Ottoman Empire and Australia with a new identity.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. All
Yes well nice take, even if much of that legend was fiction created by our official war correspondent of the time, Mr bean. Who reported among other things that the (totally incompetent) Brits at Sovala Bay were taking tea while we bled!

From his reported position in the hills behind Anzac Cove, it would, even with the most powerful binoculars, have been impossible to see anything as detailed as anyone taking tea! Moreover, the referenced troops landing at Sovala bay were mostly Irish!

In any event, if we had some actual leadership, we wouldn't have wasted so much time wandering around like Brown's cows, but landed ready to actually storm very lightly held Turkish positions before they could be reinforced; thousands of wasted lives could have been saved.

Furthermore, most of our troops were hopeless city slickers and not the natural warriors of the rural areas.

It was a proper shambles from the get go, and we and our so called leaders were responsible for the virtual bloodbath and the massive defeat that it became; rather than the reportedly incompetent Brits!

Even so, the real legends must be those civilian soldiers who stood their ground time after time, in a legendary battle of strategic withdrawal; stand and fight to fall back and fight over and over again!

Thereby effectively preventing the Japanese from employing their favorite tactic of outflanking those who thought all they needed to do was stand and fight!

So we created a legend based on myth and patent BS on the one hand, and all but ignore the real legends, who were a pitiful few fighting to keep the Nipponese army from these very shores! With almost impossible deeds of daring do!

A vastly more impressive Kakoda, teaches us how to win and also conserve lives; and in so doing earn the grudging admiration of a foe, who for the first time had been repelled; and furthermore, by a smaller less well armed force; or if you will, our Samurais; led by our best WW11 general, a former banana farmer!
Rhrosty.
Posted by Rhrosty, Friday, 24 April 2015 1:20:11 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
"One hundred years ago, the world was divided amongst different empires.Then power meant acquiring more land, and therefore the war was the norm rather than an exception."

What's changed? That's the Middle East for ya and Australia always attends a constant war or two in it.

And yes all Australians will toast the Diggers as immortalised by the Prime Minister of beer "Bow" Hawke.
Posted by plantagenet, Friday, 24 April 2015 1:33:08 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
War is not "futile" Alice. It has protected the free world from Nazism, Communism (to a large degree); stopped slavery; brought about self- determination for many people, and presently it is preventing Islamists from taking over the whole world.

It is terrible business, war; but like fossil fuels, it is going to be around for a long time yet.

For instance, after a 100 years of good relations between Australia and Turkey - including Turkey's tolerance of Australians tramping over their country annually - some Turks have retrospectively come up with the idea that Australia's and New Zealand's defeat at Gallipoli was a 'victory for Allah'. More inflammatory blah.

There will always be war and rumours of war. They will have to be fought whether we like it or not. There is no choice if we wish to survive.
Posted by ttbn, Friday, 24 April 2015 4:27:21 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
Some random points ...

Frankly, I suspect the Turks think we're completely barmy descending on their country every year to celebrate ... oh, sorry, commemorate ... the fact that they beat the crap out of us for invading their country 100 years ago. Of course, they're too polite to tell us they think we're barmy and we're too polite to mention the Armenians.

Secondly, while hundreds of thousands of young Australian men ran off to war 100 years ago, several hundreds of thousands refused to sign up because they could see it was a hypocritical power struggle between a bunch of imperial nations on the other side of the world, who ended up tripping all over their hopelessly confused system of power alliances.

Thirdly, Australia's labour and suffrage movements achieved, and defended, many more of our freedoms than the Anzacs ever did ... without firing a single shot.
Posted by Killarney, Friday, 24 April 2015 6:44:36 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
ttbn

'War ... has protected the free world from Nazism, Communism (to a large degree); stopped slavery; brought about self- determination for many people ...'

War actually CREATED Nazism in the first place. And the spoils of WWII simply handed the Soviet Communists almost half of Europe on a silver platter, after supposedly 'saving' that same half of Europe from Fascism/Nazism.

War didn't stop slavery; the abolitionist movement did, without having to go to war. The American Civil War was not about slavery (as the propaganda myth machine keeps regurgitating), but about federalism - in particular, smashing the Confederacy's slave-based economic system, which was compromising the profits of the Yankee industrialists.

War has actually DESTROYED the self-determination of billions and billions of people over many centuries and continues to destroy people's self-determination.

The only advantage war ever brings is greater profits for the already super wealthy - who also happen to control the propaganda mechanisms that keep telling us that war is necessary, benevolent and glorious.
Posted by Killarney, Friday, 24 April 2015 7:00:16 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
Killarney,

Any thoughts on the Korean War?

Was South Korea better off for the defeat of the Communist North?

Did the US benefit from the Korean oil fields?

Do General Motors and Ford love Daewoo and Hyundi?
Posted by Is Mise, Friday, 24 April 2015 8:30:44 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
" War and what is it good for".....From what I've seen lately..the men returning are coming back mentally affected by their service to the country and Iam just wondering what the women of these X-service men think, when the man that she loves cant fit into or back to family life.....I would like to know the Government's backings to these women that have or yet to be the back-bone to post traumatic stress.....which all women from all wars have to deal with.

Tally
Posted by Tally, Friday, 24 April 2015 10:00:57 PM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
The Mongols of Turkmenistan were Muslim because Ghengis Khan had selected Islam as the most suitable religion for his soldiers, as Islam was a warriors religion that justified wars of expansion. The Turks took Constantinople from the Greeks to both destroy the Eastern Roman Empire, and to cut off Europe from trade with China through the Silk Road. The Turks decided to conquer the Muslim Middle East before Europe to create a Muslim caliphate, similar to what ISIS is doing right now. Europe could wait until the time was right for invasion.

The British attack to drive the Turks right out of Europe by kicking them out of Constantinople was absolutely the right thing to do, and it came within an ace of succeeding. One more push by the combined British and French fleets would have done the job, as the Turkman forts were out of ammunition. So too, the land attack almost succeeded when the Kiwis made it to the top of the mountains before being driven back by newly arriving Muslim reinforcements under Kamal Attaturk.

Kamal Attaturk was a prescient military commander who realised that Turkey could not create a military force to compete with the Europeans unless Turkey modernised into a secular state. It was only practical military necessity that was the reason for Muslim social change in Turkey.

Australia remembers ANZAC because it was our first real military engagement and it was a total disaster with horrendous casualties. Complete military defeats are often more deeply felt than military victories, and usually result in some deep introspection about military competency, weapons and tactics. For Britain it is Dunkirk, for Germany it is Stalingrad, and for France it is Waterloo.

The claim that ANZAC unites Australia and Turkey is just a fantasy of the multiculturalists who are trying to pretend that Australians and Muslims can be friends. The west is just sorry that we did not drive out the Turks from Anatolia, and the Turks are sorry that they did not conquer Europe. Still, the Turks know that there is more than one way to skin a rat.
Posted by LEGO, Saturday, 25 April 2015 7:23:57 AM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
Only recently, the Turkish President, on an official visit to germany, enraged his hosts when he addressed a large gathering of "German" Turks and told them that they should remember that they are Turks first, and Germans second. So too, the Turkish ambassador to Austria almost got expelled from Austria when he denounced the Austrian demand that Muslims should assimilate into Australia society. The Turkish ambassador claimed that demanding that "Austrian" Turks must assimilate was a violation of their "Human Right" to retain their cultural identity as "Turks."
Posted by LEGO, Saturday, 25 April 2015 7:30:25 AM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
Killarney,

You you clearly disagree with me, which is fine. But your reasons for disagreeing are not fine. Nazis did not "invent" war. War has been waged forever, well before modern times. Your denial of war saving us from Nazism etc and self-determination for people, and abolition of slavery highlights your misunderstanding of history - if you have read any history, of course.

What I find really strange about people like you, is that you do not describe your fallback plan for the inevitable times - as now, with Islamic terrorism - when hostile people attack us and our allies. That plan would include straight out surrender, would it not?
Posted by ttbn, Saturday, 25 April 2015 11:46:43 AM
Find out more about this user Recommend this comment for deletion Return to top of page Return to Forum Main Page Copy comment URL to clipboard
  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. All

About Us :: Search :: Discuss :: Feedback :: Legals :: Privacy