The Forum > Article Comments > How did Magna Carta survive and is it relevant today? > Comments
How did Magna Carta survive and is it relevant today? : Comments
By Barry York, published 18/9/2014Resistance to usurped or tyrannical authority is an essential component of the rule of law formally recognised as such since the Magna Carta.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
-
- All
I mean and for heavens sake, we are a modern democracy, (allegedly) rather than a prison colony of convicts, needing to be managed (hammered into shape) by the principle warden/governor?
Customs, convention and precedent are all well and good, but true democracy, is only served by a stated bill of rights, such as the Magna Carta; arguably the very foundation stone of all modern democracies.
If we are a nation whose rule of law and parliamentary traditions are founded lock stock and barrel on Westminster systems, then it has to be all inclusive; rather than patently cherry picked by a conga line of asinine, intransigent, recalcitrant control freaks!?
Who argue, a bill of rights such as the (airily dismissed) Magna Carta, might confer a proxy right to bear arm; (and it does) and or, that a man's home truly is his castle, and as such, enables him to use reasonable force, including firearms, with which to defend it, his family and or retinue!
Surely a pump action shotgun loaded with non lethal bean bags, is not excessive force, for an elderly pensioner, preferred target of choice, by break and enter merchants; who by the way, used to lose their civil rights (lawful protection) when trespassing or poaching!(Theft.) Lawful entrance is only gained via the front door and subsequent invitation to enter!
Perhaps it is time for the government or referendum; (people power) to grant such a bill of irrevocable rights, inclusive of freedom of expression and the right to assemblage?
Least these two remaining immutable common law rights are also surrendered to parliamentary (tinpot potentate) control.
I mean not all that long ago a few of these control freaks? Were arguing for a return to the laws of sedition, to in effect, silence dissent (free speech)!
Democracy may be the worst form of government, but it's better than all the rest!
Rhrosty.