Leslie

'However, as in all these debates, you are wrong to designate her as "left". I am an "old leftie", and I find her views as misguided and dangerous as you do. '

fair enough Leslie and thanks.

the lack of compassion shown for those who have been waiting in refugee camps only to have their ploaces taken by an illegal immigrant is amazing. It is also very racist by their own definitions.

Like usual with the author of this type of refugee propaganda anyone who disagrees is a racist.

Now to get very controversial - The boat that sank and all previous sinkings I have NO sympathy at all for them EXCEPT the children who were recklessly put in a situation whereby they died by there parents greed.

They passed through many safe countries on there journey, in those countries they would have been under UN protection which is a tent some food and water. GREED bought them here because unlike Germany and other countries who give them food stamps and like $32 we give them MUCH more they are guaranteed money and housing free medical and legal representation. Unlike in Malaysia and Indonesia who give them nothing.

Also Quote "$217 per week" wrong the charities look after them as well and that cost is hidden but paid by the taxpayers.

TPV are a start at least then we won't have to support them for life.

So now do we understand the Anti Genocide "Mantra", Lyn Bender sees this as a race problem, fair enough so do I, Anti Racist is a code word for Anti White:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dpeMuUQQkc

The Human Rights & Equal Opportunities Act is interesting, particular the section that states 'Australians are not a race'. Context makes it clear that application is 'white persons of anglo-saxon ancestry') Interestingly almost the exact wording is found in comparable laws in the UK, the US, Canada & the Irish Republic. It begs the question 'HOW' ??

Philip S,
Notice that Lyn and her ilk don't expect Indonesians or Malaysians to care for these "refugees" but see it as an absolute obligation of White people and ONLY White people. She then makes outrageous statements vilifying my ethnic group and my gender and suggesting that "our" treatment of Aboriginals renders us indebted to all non Whites, that White "Racism" is an eternal crime which transcends time and place.
No more, there's no need to argue, no need to quote statistics or discuss anything at all with the likes of Lyn Bender, we're fed up, the "R Word" is just a justification for acts in support of genocide, when someone uses that racial slur just fire back:
"In your opinion I'm a racist, you're just saying that because I'm White, Anti Racist is just a code word for Anti White".