The Forum > Article Comments > Evolutionary conundrums for believers > Comments
Evolutionary conundrums for believers : Comments
By Glen Coulton, published 23/1/2013If God wanted hordes of us humans hanging out in heaven with him, why didn't he just put us there from the word go?
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- Page 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
-
- All
<Perhaps, Glen C, if you cannot frame the question without a sneer, you should consider whether you might be asking the wrong question. As far as I can tell, your entire article led to the final line...]>
You seem very pleased with your conclusion that I framed my question with a sneer but you've not demonstrated that I did. I never felt any need to sneer or any need to justify asking the question whose asking upsets you so much. Do you regard raising objections to firmly held beliefs as necessarily sneering or are they only sneering when the firmly held beliefs are religious?
And is there anything wrong with preceding a final question by establishing relevant premises? It's done quite often.
<What did you consider to be the purpose of that question when you wrote it, other than to make the "parent and believer" feel really, really small, their beliefs having been smashed to smithereens on the pulpit of your superciliously-delivered logic?>
The purpose of the question was to give people who are agonising over whether to reject the beliefs they were indoctrinated in one more reason for feeling that it's OK to do so. It was one attempt to counter the indoctrination such people have had visited upon them by religious proselytisers for centuries, and still do. Am I not allowed even one small word of encouragement to them?
And is the pertinence of a logical objection to be judged by whether you feel it was posed superciliously? You seem to be carefully avoiding engaging with whether the question was a good one. You seem more interested in finding fault with me than with it.
I notice, though, your prediction that my question will lead to "their beliefs having been smashed". Do you really think it was that good?
Continued…