The Forum > Article Comments > Puppy slaughter in Australia: what's all the fuss? > Comments
Puppy slaughter in Australia: what's all the fuss? : Comments
By Nicholas Pendergrast, published 21/9/2012But why is the slaughter of this puppy considered animal cruelty, while the slaughter of other animals is considered standard practise?
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 15
- 16
- 17
- Page 18
-
- All
Ah Nick, but you are not out there in nature, giving animals that option. Those wild dogs will just keep ripping herbivores to bits,
due to lack of resources. Which is what it comes down to, really.
Every creature needs to make a living, or they go extinct. Some species make a living, by having been domesticated. Cattle and sheep for instance, would largely be extinct otherwise. So its all about
win-win situations really. My sheep win, they have a cushy lifestyle,
suffering is down to an absolute minimum. Fed through droughts,
treated for sickness, protected from predators.
Win-win is as good as you can get in life. Everyone benefits.
*I have seen many animals “protesting” and struggling to avoid slaughter*
Perhaps that is because you know far less about animals, then you
think that you do. I suggest that you read up a bit on Temple Grandin
and what she thinks. The meat industry has had to admit that even they don't know much about animals. So she advises them how to think
like a cow or a sheep. A cow or sheep will baulk at a plastic bag
in a race, or a piece of paper even. Poorly designed yards are
a major issue. Poor stockmanship is a major issue. But with things
like low stress stock handling, where people learn to see the
perspective of an animal, they will walk right up to the point of
slaughter without even a hesitation. Because they really are not
aware as to what comes next.