The Forum > Article Comments > The 'maths' behind the Shalit prisoner swap > Comments
The 'maths' behind the Shalit prisoner swap : Comments
By Manny Waks and Geoffrey Winn, published 31/10/2011No matter how tortuous the negotiation that preceded Shalit's release, it is the moral calculation, once reached by the Netanyahu Government, that most readily reconciles the gross discrepancy in the numbers.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Page 4
-
- All
Yes, and I condemn all the above countries in the same way as I condemn Israel.
Just as it is inconceivable to justify the murder of innocent diners or bus-travelers, so it is inconceivable to justify the incarceration and enslavement of innocent people who committed no crime without their consent, let alone subjecting them to the extra risk of being injured or dying in battle which ordinary imprisoned criminals do not suffer, and let alone children whose only "crime" is to be born in a certain place and reaching the age of 18 in relative health.
I am myself a victim of conscription, I still occasionally suffer nightmares as a result, and one of the main reasons that I immigrated to Australia is that here we do not have that barbaric practice.