The Forum > Article Comments > Public schools need ethics, not religious education > Comments
Public schools need ethics, not religious education : Comments
By Glen Coulton, published 2/7/2010Religion, especially Christianity, is not essential to the teaching and development of a sound ethical sense.
- Pages:
-
- 1
- 2
- 3
- ...
- 12
- 13
- 14
- Page 15
- 16
- 17
- 18
-
- All
I was not aware that I'd raised the issue of creation except in a passing comment about how divided the various Christian churches are on the question of evolution. I'd agree that if there really were a god and if we knew how it wanted us to behave, then we would be smart to fall in line with its wishes, it being (presumably) much more powerful than us and likely to smite us if we annoyed it. That is, if it has the same kind of personality failings that we mere humans have. In the near certain absence of a god, I think we should just go with the “Do unto others” rule that served the ancient Egyptians, Indians, Chinese, Greeks and others so well for some many centuries that the chaps who managed to get their memoirs accepted into one or other of the collections that came to be known as the bible reprised it in such places as Matthew 7:12 (if I remember correctly). None of which stops certain people today from claiming that the rule was invented by Christ, which is a bit like crediting Gen X with the invention of sex.
Anyway, you wouldn’t want to place too much faith in what some religion insists is the word of god when the religions cannot even agree on whether intelligent design is intelligent or hog wash. All the major Christian churches, by the way, have moved or are inexorably moving, to the latter view. In this circumstance, it seems particularly short sighted of people to waste the one life they‘ll get trying to observe an ethic which is nothing more than some innocents’ wildly optimistic guesses about how their imaginary friend in the sky wants us to behave.
BTW, anyone who disputes the suggestion that if we had been created by a god, he/she/it must have been a lousy designer need only Google “human design flaws”.