The Forum > Article Comments > An ambit claim for the Ruddfest 2020 > Comments
An ambit claim for the Ruddfest 2020 : Comments
By Valerie Yule, published 11/3/20082020 summit: a government can work for fairness through the visions it sets, by the fair laws it makes and the injustices it removes.
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
The buisiness of developing co-ordinated public policy positions between all three tiers of governments has been the responsibility of COAG, the Coalition of Australian Governments. It's time to recogognise that COAG's not working to produce the clear and decisive actions Australia needs to take on climate change, infrastructure, resources, health, education, IR, commerce, etc. Only radical surgery on our body politic can fix a broken federal structure.
COAG meetings have been notable for their long running and trenchant disagreements on vital issues of national importance. In relation to the agreements that have been made, the concessions in reaching a concensus have produced poor policies that have taken years to implement. Weak enforcement mechanisms encourage cheating.
What surgery is required for our system of government? Rudd's ambit could be to seek the powers he needs through referral of functions by the states. If that doesn't happen, then the commonwealth can attempt legislative take-over of all law making powers on issues of national importance. In today's world, that's just about everything.
Incentives to the states may help with the former approach, but if a turf dispute needs adjudication, then the High Court will determine where power really lies. The court has consistently taken a very broad view of the commonwealth government's various heads of power to make national laws rendering inconsistent state laws void.
Once national laws have been made by the Australian parliament, then Rudd's government can deliver the kind of fair programs and priority infrastructure that local communities desperately need. Without reform, he doesn't stand a chance.
The states have an important trasitional role before their medium to long term dissolution. That's to facititate an orderly transition of their functions, resources and employees to the other two tiers of government. Strong leadership is about meeting the challenges that our time calls from our Prime Minister.