The Forum > Article Comments > The real hoax of organ donation > Comments
The real hoax of organ donation : Comments
By Chris Devir, published 19/6/2007Organs that don’t get transplanted are burnt or buried: they are completely wasted.
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
-
- All
On the one hand, I have grave fears - likely unfounded, of lying in the street after a car crash having the ambulance officers overtop of me saying to each other 'he's too far gone, let him go and we'll save ten lives with his insides' type of thing.
No, seriously though, with the stories I heard a few years ago of Packer buying our medical records (something along those lines - if anyone knows please let me know what it was about) for some marketing reason.
I can see, unless there were serious checks and balances, a Packer type mogul scouring the lists for suitable donors if he were ever in need - and perhaps the person with the match might go missing.
Probably too many Sci-Fi thrillers have made me paranoid.
I know there is no point taking our organs with us when we die, I guess like you say, it's all about education. Just the other night I saw a documentary segment on Dateline I think, about this very topic.
Poor people in Pakistan were being abused by their wealthy class, with Doctors eagerly handing out the equivalent of $4000US (which is no doubt a lot to such people) for a kidney to sell to a wealthy Arab, Asian, or even westerner.
This turns people off.
However, I have no doubt that if looked into, a system could be set up that would put my mind at ease. If this could be done, and I would take more convincing than most, most would jump on board.
I believe that Dutch fake show was a wake-up call, and they're right -it's got us all talking about it again, which is important.
Good article.
We need to get serious about this topic. I have brothers who are listed as organ donors but I keep thinking it's a little scary.
And good on the Dutch for being the part of the human conscience that put this issue where it belongs, in the fore.