The Forum > Article Comments > Why we must take the vaccine > Comments
Why we must take the vaccine : Comments
By Peter Bowden, published 13/12/2021John Ruddick in the current issue of The Statesman has published an article: 'I won't take a COVID vaccine. Here's why'. It is a pseudo-philosophical argument.
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
-
- All
But tell me, why do we have this obligation?
You cite various religious leaders and philosophers who make similar assertions to yours, as if that answers the question, but it doesn’t.
People can assert anything they like and perhaps many people can assert the same thing, but that in itself doesn’t give their assertions any authority or make them “right”.
Hitler made many assertions and many Nazis agreed with him. I presume you would think Hitler and the Nazis were “wrong” but what makes him wrong and say, Buddha, “right” in what he asserted?
You seem to have some unstated idea of how the world/universe is supposed to be. If so, where do you get this idea from?
If the world has just happened to unintentionally come into existence for no purpose, then there is no state that the world/universe is meant to be in. Thus, if that were true, then no one would have any obligation to anyone or anything.
You need to provide your foundational beliefs before you worry about people getting vaccinated or not.