The Forum > Article Comments > Focus on literacy > Comments
Focus on literacy : Comments
By Victor Perton, published 30/9/2005Victor Perton argues Steve Bracks fails his own literacy and numeracy tests.
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
1) Since there is a teacher shortage in many areas, there is no point arguing about simply increasing the teaching benchmark standards until you suggest a way to either solve the shortage problem or solve the the problem of getting people with greater aptitude to become teachers (Incidentally, I have no idea why you think that there is no entrance exam to teacher training, there is, its called a year 12 mark and therefore a university entrance score. In addition, for the graduate diploma, you must have an initial degree). If you simply increase the benchmark without doing either of those, you will simply have less trained teachers. What do you then intend to do with schools that cannot then get even poorer teachers ? How do you intend to create better teacher training at a state level for new teachers, when the teaching colleagues for new students (i.e., universities) are funded at the federal level ? Clearly, there are problems that need to be solved that are neccesary precursors to increasing benchmarks.
2) Literacy and numeracy has been declining through Cain, Kirner, Kennett and now Bracks, yet only the name of Bracks is mentioned.
3) Whilst funding organizations to help semi-literate parents is a good idea, the percentage of semi-literate parents is much smaller than the number of children with problems. Thus you can fund these organizations all you want, but most of the problems will still be there. Also, what evidence is there that these organizations are better than the goverment run programs ?
4) Continuing on, since many of the after school programs are already a failure (as noted by yourself), how do you intend to create ones that are not ?
5) Simply not promoting people through the grade levels is no solution. Not being able to read and write in year 10 is no different to not being able to read and write in year 12. Nor is it any different to not being able to read and write when you drop out of school.