The Forum > Article Comments > NSW election result opens way for a radically centrist approach > Comments
NSW election result opens way for a radically centrist approach : Comments
By Vern Hughes, published 2/5/2011The destruction of the NSW Labor machine and the failure of the Greens shows that Australia will never embrace radical left solutions.
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
- Pages:
-
- Page 1
-
- All
re:Left parties alienating voters: the author mentions the stall in the growth of the Greens and the decline of the Democrats. But it was exactly when Meg Lees attempted to be 'centrist' that the Democrats' support base collapsed. And meanwhile it has been exactly the Greens' status as 'the' left-wing party that saw its support base grow, stabilising at about 10%. (after about two decades of gradual growth)
Finally: There is a base of voters Labor has long alienated by abandoning class politics. There are many working class voters - and alienated Lumpenproletariat elements - who do not identify with liberalism on issues such as refugees. This has provided a conservative wedge; aided and abbetted by fear and hate mongering by right-wing media elements.
But there is no reason to suppose this base might not return to Labor should Labor consistently appeal to their material interests. And this is not to say the cultural struggle for social liberalism is not winnable amongst the mass of working people over the long term. (as changing attitude to multiculturalism and sexuality have shown)
The 'Third Way' has some redeeming elements: social inclusion, protection of the vulnerable, cosmopolitanism. But in taking 'the path of least resistance' it forgets the dignity and worth of the broad mass of labour; as well as problems of economic power; and many use it to rationalise what is effectively labour conscription.
Redistribution for social and economic justice, provision of a robust welfare state, a strategic mixed economy - all remain relevant social democratic causes. Historically this is the social democratic mainstream. But a take on the 'Third Way' that 'sways with the wind' - adapting to the relative Centre without contesting its meaning - is not the answer.